Canon PowerShot A5
Canon's "Digital ELPHs" arrive - good things in small packages!
||Compact, rugged case|
||Excellent macro capability|
||Great low-light ability (up to ISO400)|
||Panorama support, including 2x2 matrix!|
Canon was one of the first digital camera manufacturers to reach beyond the
"VGA" resolution category, with their original PowerShot 600. At the
time, the PowerShot 600 broke new ground and established a benchmark for sharpness
and image quality. Since then, Canon has lain quiet for a long time, leading
to much speculation about their long-term plans relative to digital photography.
With the release of the PowerShot A5 (and the forthcoming PowerShot Pro 70)
though, Canon has not only conclusively demonstrated its commitment to digital
photography, but returned to the cutting edge of digital camera technology as
well. In the A5, we find a very appealingly packaged 800K-pixel camera with
a commanding set of capabilities (including an effective ISO speed reaching
as high as 400).
If you've ever seen one of Canon's APS-format ELPH film cameras, the A5 will be immediately familiar: We expect to see the term "Digital ELPH" used frequently to describe it. Truly a shirt-pocket camera, the A5 provides truly excellent image quality in a very compact package. A 1/3", 810,000-pixel CCD captures 1024x768 pixel images at 10 bits per channel. (The 30 total bits captured for the three color channels are reduced to the "best" 24 bits in the finished image files.) Images are stored in a total of 4 different quality/size modes, using two compression levels for both full-size and the reduced 512x384 pixel resolution "economy" mode. The A5 includes both an optical viewfinder and back-panel LCD screen for framing, and includes a high-quality (glass) autofocus lens, built-in multi-mode flash, and useful software.
As mentioned above, the PowerShot A5 looks like nothing so much as a digital version of the popular ELPH pocket point & shoot film camera. The rectangular body is entirely constructed from anodized aluminum, conveying a very rugged feel. One nice touch is the inclusion of a metal tripod socket: To date, this is the only point & shoot digital camera we've tested equipped with a metal tripod socket -- We confess to being somewhat nervous about the longevity of the plastic sockets on other digital cameras.
Our ham-handed tester found the diminutive A5 a little small to hold, but had
no difficult accessing the controls.. At 4.1 x 2.7 x 1.3 inches (103 x 68 x
32.5 mm) and 8.1 ounces (230 gm) minus the batteries, it is compact enough to
fit into almost any shirt pocket, yet still has a solid "feel" during
use. You turn the camera on by rotating the "mode dial" on the camera
top, which not only turns on the camera electronics, but also automatically
retracts the metal lens cover, another nice touch.
In common with many other digital cameras on the market today, the PowerShot A5 addresses the "optical vs. LCD" viewfinder controversy by providing both. A bright optical viewfinder provides framing marks for the "normal" mode of the camera, and the back-panel LCD screen can be used either as a viewfinder (a necessity when operating in "macro" mode), or to review images already captured. You can turn the LCD viewfinder on or off at any time by pressing the metal "LCD" button on the back of the camera when in "capture" mode. Like all such panels, the LCD on the A5 is moderately power-hungry, so you'll want to be judicious in its use to conserve battery life. Fortunately, we found the A5's optical viewfinder more than adequate for most picture-taking, and about the only time we really felt a need for the LCD viewer was when doing macro photography.
In common with most other digital point & shoots we've tested, we found that the LCD panel on the A5 didn't quite show the entire field of view of the image sensor. If you frame a subject exactly using the LCD viewfinder, you'll discover that the final image includes about another 5-10% of the total image area around the outside of the frame. This took a little getting used to when shooting some of our more analytical subjects (such as the resolution target), which required very precise framing. Most casual shooters should find this no limitation however.
The PowerShot A5's LCD panel incorporates two significant features relative
to most other digital point & shoots on the market: A very sharp "TFT"
screen, and the option to boost the screen brightness for outdoor shooting.
As technology moves forward, we expect TFT LCD panels to appear in other cameras
as well, but for now, the panel on the A5 is the sharpest we've seen. (It's
officially described as a "low-temperature polysilicon thin-film transistor"
design. The "low-temperature" polysilicon fabrication is apparently
a significant factor in its sharpness, according to a Canon engineer we spoke
with.) We found the "bright" mode on the display particularly welcome
when working with it outdoors on a bright day: While still no match for direct
sunlight, the extra brightness is a real help in seeing what you're focusing
on or what you've already captured. As you might expect though, the added brightness
comes at the expense of drastically curtailed battery life. We didn't do any
quantitative tests of this, but would guess that running the display with the
brightness turned up cuts battery life at least in half, and possibly more.
At the professional end of the 35mm film-camera spectrum, Canon is renowned for the quality of their optics. While we don't know the details of the A5's lens construction (other than a notation in the documentation that it is an all-glass, aspheric design), its performance certainly seemed worthy of the Canon heritage. With a focal length equivalent to a 35mm lens on a 35mm camera, the fast f2.5 lens captures a slightly wider than "normal" field of view. (Moderate wide-angle lenses of this type are the norm for most point and shoot cameras, whether film or digital. In most point and shoot applications, the ability to fit more of the subject into the frame is a decided plus.)
As we go to "press" ("web"?) with this review, we're waiting for confirmation back from Canon on the A5's lens aperture: The spec sheet states that it is a "f2.5" lens, giving no indication of any smaller aperture. (This has been amended to indicate a minimum aperture of f11, as of 5/20/98.)
The lens autofocuses from 20 inches (50cm) to infinity in "normal" mode, and from 3.5 to 20 inches (9 to 50 cm) in "macro" mode. The macro mode provides for close-ups of small objects, covering an area of roughly 2.4 x 3.2 inches (6.2 x 8.2 cm) at closest approach. (For reference, the small brooch in the "macro" test shot is about 1.05 inches (27 mm) wide.) This is exceptionally good macro performance for a point and shoot camera, although the slightly wide-angle lens makes for shorter working distances than would a longer focal length.
A very welcome feature on the A5 was its built-in illuminator for the passive
autofocus system: When shooting in low light levels, the camera projects a bright,
striped beam from an on-board LED onto the subject, just before the shutter
fires. This provides a visible "target" for the autofocus system,
even in total darkness. Low-light autofocus capability (or the apparent lack
thereof) on various digital camera models has been a hot topic of discussion
in internet news groups. The autofocus illuminator of the A5 still won't save
you from blurred pictures caused by camera shake (see our note below, under
"exposure"), but should almost completely banish the problem of achieving
correct focus under low-light conditions.
The PowerShot A5 is rated at an equivalent ISO speed of either 100 or 400, depending on the image size selected: Large-size images are captured with an effective ISO speed of 100, while the smaller image size uses "binning" on the CCD array to increase the effective sensitivity to ISO 400. Unfortunately, we didn't have the opportunity to test the high-sensitivity ISO 400 mode: We didn't realize the higher sensitivity was only available in the low-resolution mode, and so performed most of our testing at the higher resolution. It's interesting though, that we found ourselves exclaiming over the A5's low-light performance, even at the high-resolution setting.
With a shutter speed range of 1/6 to 1/750 seconds, Canon rates the usable "metering range" of the camera as extending from EV 5 to EV 16.5. (When we first received our review unit, Canon had rated at EV 7.6 - 16.5, which we felt was far too conservative on the low end. Since then, they've amended the specification to extend down to EV 5, a value consistent with our own testing.)
The autoexposure system works through the lens (TTL), and so is less likely to be affected by stray light than otherwise. As noted earlier, the camera automatically chooses the best combination of f-stop and shutter speed for the situation at hand. A 10 second self-timer gives the photographer time to get into the picture him/herself.
IMPORTANT NOTE: The 1/6 second lower limit on shutter speed can be a great help in getting shots in conditions that would otherwise be too dark. This is a long exposure though, well beyond most people's ability to hold the camera steady enough to render a sharp image. Use a tripod when it's that dark! A few pros may venture to hand-hold a 1/6 second exposure, but it's just about guaranteed that most amateurs will have a hard time below 1/30 or even 1/60. 'Nuff said...
Like any autoexposure system, that of the PowerShot A5 is subject to being "fooled" by unusual subjects, whether a light object against a dark background, a backlit subject, or one that's unusually uniform in overall brightness (such as a snow scene). To accommodate these situations, Canon includes an exposure adjustment control with a range of +/- 2 f-stop (EV value) in 1/3 f-stop increments, to accommodate these situations. Thus, if you think the situation calls for it, you can request more or less exposure by adjusting the exposure-compensation setting.
While the range and fine control of the exposure-compensation on the A5 was excellent, we found the procedure for setting it to be rather vexing: To begin with, exposure compensation can only be selected when the camera is operating in "program" mode, requiring the mode dial to be set accordingly prior to the exposure. (In fairness though, this is also a blessing, as the camera remembers the program-mode settings from one time to the next, allowing you to switch back and forth between exposure-compensation and full automatic operation very quickly.) Our biggest complaint with the exposure compensation system though, was the number of back-panel menu/button operations we had to cycle through to effect a change. We counted no fewer than 6 button-pushes needed to change the exposure compensation setting. For the record, we much prefer exposure compensation adjustments that can be made "on the fly," without navigating a series of menus. Despite our gripes about the user interface though, we really liked the degree of control afforded by the 1/3-stop increments, and the wide +/- 2EV adjustment range.
We also liked the focus/exposure lock function of the A5, that allows you to pre-set the exposure prior to the shot itself: Pressing the shutter button halfway actuates the autofocus and autoexposure systems, without triggering the shutter itself. Once the exposure and focus is set in this fashion, they will stay "locked" at the selected settings as long as you continue to hold down the shutter button. With this feature, you can easily accommodate off-center subjects by turning to center them, locking the focus and exposure, then turning back to frame the shot to your liking before firing the shutter.
The built-in automatic flash has a working range of 8 inches to 11.5 feet (0.2 to 3.5 meters), and offers the standard set of operating modes, including "red-eye" reduction, force fill, automatic, and of course "off," for those situations in which you want the camera to just do its best with the light available.
The A5's white-balance compensation is automatic, and does a good job of correcting for widely varying lighting conditions. The "indoor portrait" test shot retained enough of the warmth of the incandescent lighting to preserve the original "feeling," without the color cast overpowering the colors of the subject.
In its normal operating mode, the PowerShot A5 cycles fairly rapidly between
exposures, even in high-resolution mode: We timed the minimum interval between
exposures at about 3 seconds. (This is quite a bit faster than most digital
cameras, particularly higher-resolution ones.) If this isn't fast enough for
you, the camera also has a "continuous" mode, in which the camera
will record up to 15 frames at one-second intervals, as long as the shutter
button is held down, and sufficient memory is free. Images captured in continuous
mode are only stored at the small size of 512x384 pixels though.
Operation and User Interface
The PowerShot A5 makes extensive use of its bright, clear LCD panel for user-interface functions, as well as image preview/review. The camera is controlled by a top-mounted, thumb-operated "mode dial," and a total of six pushbuttons plus the shutter release button.
One of the first surprises we encountered with the A5's user interface was the option to set the language used for the menus to our choice of no less than 10 different languages! (English, German, French, Netherlands, Dutch, Swiss, Italian, Norwegian, Swedish, or Spanish) Being only monolingual even on our best days, we opted for English. (It turns out our review unit had the European ROM set, hence the broad range of languages. US versions will only support English, French, German, and Japanese.) The language menu is accessed by setting the control knob to Play mode (see below), and then pressing the Set and Macro/Jump buttons simultaneously.
Menus controlling various camera functions can be accessed in most camera modes by pressing the "menu" button on the back panel. The contents of the menu displayed will vary, depending on the mode the camera happens to be in at the time.
Major camera modes are selected via the top-mounted "mode dial" thumbwheel
that also serves as the power switch (the camera is off when the dial is set
to the "Locked" position. Available camera modes are automatic or
"program" (manual) image acquisition, "stitch assist" mode
for panoramic or mosaic-shooting support, play mode, "multi" mode,
and PC mode. Turning the camera on by rotating the mode dial out of the locked
position automatically retracts the protective metal lens cover.
"Auto" mode is the setting you'll probably use for most of your picture-taking: In this mode, focus, exposure, white balance, and flash operation are all automatically set by the camera itself. No modification of the automatic settings is provided for, that capability being reserved for "program" mode. Auto mode also limits you to the "large" image size, although you can select either of the two levels of compression that are available. Auto mode does allow you to use the A5's macro capability, however.
In "Program" mode, you can manually control the flash setting, turning it on (forced or "fill" flash), off, or enabling the red-eye reduction function. In this mode, focus, exposure, and white balance are still automatically controlled, although you can override the automatic exposure control by setting an exposure-compensation value of up to +/- 2EV units, as described earlier. Program mode also allows you to select the "small" image format, as well as the CCD Raw (no compression) image-storage mode. Finally, Program mode allows you to select either single-shot or continuous shooting, or the self-timer function.
At first, we found the need to switch to "program" mode to make even the simplest adjustment annoying, but we soon came to appreciate the ability to preserve custom camera settings, and to switch rapidly between the custom setup and the fully automatic defaults. - The "program" mode settings are stored separately, so you can (for instance) adjust the settings for indoor, non-flash shooting, perhaps including some exposure compensation, and then quickly switch back and forth between the default setting (which would use the flash) and the custom non-flash configuration with a flick of your thumb on the control wheel. We actually found this capability quite useful in various shooting situations.
While in either Auto or Program modes, the control menu presents functions relevant to image recording. You can select between two different image compression levels for file storage, or turn the "Review" function of the LCD panel on or off. (When Review is enabled, the LCD illuminates briefly after each shot is taken to show you what you just captured. You can also turn the LCD on or off manually at any time by pressing the rear-panel "LCD" button.) The Record menu also allows you to reset the system of file numbers (described below, under image storage) assigned to images.
The Record menu also branches to a "setup" sub-menu, allowing control
of LCD brightness, audible alerts, power saving functions, overall camera reset,
and date/time setting.
Once you've captured images, you'll of course want to view them. This is accomplished by selecting either "Play" or "Multi" mode with the mode dial. Operation of these two modes is very similar, the only difference being that the "multi" mode displays images as 9 thumbnails at a time. In play mode, the "+" and "=" buttons display the next or previous recorded image, while the Macro/Jump button selects "jump" mode, in which the +/- buttons skip to the last or first image on the CF card, respectively. In multi mode, images are displayed in groups of nine, and the currently-selected image is indicated by a green border. You can move the selection box forward or back one image at a time by pressing the + or - button, or to the next or previous group of nine images when jump mode is enabled. When you switch from Multi back to Play mode, the currently-selected image will be displayed full-size on the LCD screen.
In Play mode, the menu system provides a variety of functions relevant to viewing or reviewing your images, and also supports image-marking for subsequent direct printing via a Canon photo-quality printer.
The first entry on the Play menu is "show info," which displays the current image number, total number of images on the CF card, file number, creation date & time, and protection setting icon. (Another Play menu entry lets you "protect" selected images, so they won't be erased when an "erase all" function is performed.)
The "slide show" Play menu entry lets you set the camera to scroll through images stored in memory, specifying how long each is displayed, and whether the show will loop back to the beginning when it reaches the end. This feature is becoming increasingly common on digital cameras, but Canon has taken it a step further by not only allowing you to mark which images to include in a slide show, but also by providing for three different slide shows to be held in the camera simultaneously. Images on the CF card may appear in one, all, some, or none of the three shows interchangeably. Of course, you can also select "all images" when you want to cycle through the entire memory card. Options for display time can be set to Manual (using the +/- buttons), or 3, 5, or 10-second intervals per slide. Slide shows always display images in the order in which they were stored on the CF card.
Storage management is provided by the "erase" function. With it, you can erase images individually, while scrolling through thumbnails of the images on the card, or all at once. As mentioned earlier, you may optionally "protect" some images so that they will survive an "erase all" function.
We briefly mentioned earlier that the A5 can be used with a small photo printer, also marketed by Canon. We don't have specifications for it, but the CD-200 printer can accept CF cards from the A5 directly, to provide continuous-tone prints approximating conventional prints of the sort you'd get at a drugstore. In similar fashion to marking/unmarking images for slide shows, you can also mark/unmark pictures to be printed on the CD-200. Once the desired image files have been marked, you simply remove the CF card from the camera, plug it into the printer, and hit the Print button - the printer does the rest, independently of the camera.
Setup functions accessible from the Play menu include those described previously
for the Record mode, plus options for setting the date/time, formatting a CF
card, and choosing the menu language.
Stitch Assist Mode
A number of digital cameras now provide features that support the creation of "panoramas" by stitching-together multiple images. Here again though, Canon has gone most of the industry one better: Not only does the PowerShot A5 support conventional panoramas, including both horizontal and vertical camera orientations, but it offers a unique 2x2 matrix stitching mode as well. Like "program" mode, stitch assist mode also enables several manual camera functions, including flash mode selection, and macro operation.
In all the stitching modes, the A5 leaves a portion of the previous image (or images, in the case of the 2x2 matrix) on the LCD screen, while running the LCD as a "live" viewfinder showing what the camera is currently pointed at. Having the adjoining piece(s) of the panorama or matrix available on-screen while you're framing the next shot is a tremendous help in achieving good alignment between adjacent images, a critical requirement for good final "stitch" results. You'll still probably want to use a tripod and possibly even one of the special pan heads sold for such purposes, rather than hand-holding the camera, but even with a tripod, the stitch assist is very helpful. Finally, the A5 offers the capability to re-shoot an image that's already part of a panorama, if you're not happy with the orientation, exposure, etc. As far as we know, this ability to drop back into the middle of a sequence of panorama shots to re-shoot a bad image is unique to Canon and the A5.
As we mentioned, direct support in the camera for assembling a 2x2 matrix of
images is unique in our experience. The net result is a very high resolution
image. (You'll necessarily lose some image area to the required overlap between
adjacent images, but you can easily achieve 1600 x 1200 images in this manner.)
Image Storage and Interface
The PowerShot A5 stores images on a removable CompactFlash card, with a capacious 8 MB unit included as standard equipment. These cards are quite compact, although not as much so as the SSFDC "SmartMedia" cards used in some cameras. The advantage of the CF cards though, is that they are available in very large sizes (as of this writing, up to 48 meg), for quite reasonable prices. Adapters allowing CF cards to be read in standard PC-card slots on laptops are available from either Canon or third parties, and well worth the modest cost if your computer has PC-card slots: Downloads via the PC slot take seconds, as compared to minutes for transfers over a serial cable.
The maximum number of images that can be stored on each card varies quite a bit, depending on the combination of image size and compression level selected. As mentioned earlier, the A5 saves images as standard JPEG files (making it a "finished file" camera) at two different image sizes (1024x768 and 512x384) and two different compression settings (normal and fine), all selectable by the user. A fifth option is to store image in a "CCD Raw mode, in which the raw data from the CCD is stored directly on the card, without any in-camera processing. The Raw mode saves uncompressed files of 960x768 pixels, in a proprietary format. Average file sizes range from 940 KB for the Raw mode through 180 KB for Large/Fine images, to 85 KB for Large/Normal mode, all the way down to 30 KB for Small/Normal mode. With the included 8MB CF card, these file sizes translate to a capacity of 8 - 236 images per card. The large memory capacity will doubtless encourage most people to save images in the Large/Fine mode, allowing an average of 44 images per card.
As a minor side note, we liked the fact that we could easily insert or remove the CF card while the camera was mounted on a tripod. Not a big thing, but some cameras use a bottom-mounted latch for the CF socket, meaning you have to unmount it from a tripod in order to pull the card. We also liked the consecutive numbering system for the image files: The camera keeps a running count of exposures, and attaches a unique number to each image. Images are automatically placed in folders on the CF card, and a new folder is created for every 50 image files. Thus, when you download the images onto your hard disk, you never have problems with image files having the same name overwriting each other. Whenever you change the camera's battery, the file count jumps to the next 50-unit block. As mentioned earlier, this file count can be manually reset at any time via the Record menu interface.
Data can be downloaded from the camera via a standard serial interface, at
a maximum speed of 115 Kbaud. Download of a typical Large/Fine mode image took
about 18 seconds on our standard 133MHz, non-MMX Pentium PC. (Standard-quality
images take about half as long to download.) Canon provides two pieces of software
for downloading images from the camera: A Photoshop(tm) acquire plug-in for
Mac users, and a TWAIN driver for the Windows crowd. On their respective platforms,
these programs provide pretty universal coverage: Many Mac-based imaging programs
support the Photoshop plug-in standard, while TWAIN support is nearly universal
In addition to the serial computer interface, the PowerShot A5 also has a connector for displaying images via standard NTSC video. This is a capability we've generally found more useful than we first expected: Connected to a TV with a video input jack, the A5 becomes a portable presentation machine! Since you can upload images back into the camera, you can select the best/most appropriate shots, put titles on them with the included PhotoImpact (Windows) software, load them back into the camera, and then play them back for a presentation. As frequent business travelers, we've also found digital cameras a great way for the family back home to feel more connected with our business activities: A "slide show" of sights and people from a business trip is great for sharing the events of the trip with the kids. (And with the spouse left behind!)
The PowerShot A5 can be powered either by an (included) high-capacity rechargeable NiMH battery pack, or by a standard 2CR5 lithium battery (available at most camera stores). Additional NiMH battery packs can be purchased separately from Canon. This combination strikes us as a good working solution, and the inclusion of the NiMH battery pack as standard equipment is especially welcome: Our standard recommendation for new digital camera owners is to buy a set of high-capacity NiMH AA cells. We found the Canon NiMH battery pack provided good power longevity, and recharged quickly in the provided AC adapter/charger unit. With a second battery pack, you could literally shoot continuously, with one pack charging while the other was in the camera.
The ability to use a standard 2CR5 lithium cell for "emergency backup" power is very welcome too: The cell is small enough to not constitute an onerous burden for the roving photographer, and the exceptional shelf-life of lithium batteries (measured in years) means that a single backup battery could last the life of the camera. (A word to the wise though: Even a fully-charged NiMH pack has a fairly limited shelf-life, due to their tendency to self-discharge - Be sure to give your NiMH packs a boost before any extended outings!)
The A5's battery charger also serves as an AC adapter, through the use of a dummy battery pack that connects via a cord to the charger unit. That's right: A dummy battery pack! - The contraption looks exactly like the standard battery pack, only it has a cord extending from the bottom of it. To use it, you just insert it into the camera in place of the normal pack, and plug the cord into the charger. Although we can't say why, given its faintly Rube-Goldbergish appearance, we actually liked the "dummy battery" better than the standard plug-the-cord-into-the-tiny-socket approach of most cameras. By contrast though, some users may find it inconvenient to physically remove the battery every time they want to run from AC power. One thing we didn't like about the arrangement was the inability to both power the camera via the adapter and charge a battery simultaneously: You can only do one or the other.
IMPORTANT NOTE (For first-time A5 users): This is so embarrassing that we almost
didn't include it, but finally decided that the grief it might save our readers
would be well-worth our deflated egos. When we first received our eval sample
of the A5, we immediately tore into the packaging, slapped the battery and CF
card into the unit, and . . . nothing! Deadness, total lack of electronic activity.
We were within a hairsbreadth of calling Canon when we happened to slide the
latch on the battery compartment cover into the "locked" position.
Voila! - It turns out there's a switch hidden in the battery compartment cover,
and the camera won't power-up unless the cover is locked. For some reason, we
found the action of locking the battery compartment completely unintuitive,
perhaps because it latches shut on its own even if the lock isn't set. There
- we've humiliated ourselves publicly, but probably saved thousands of readers
five minutes of frustration. (Not to mention saved Canon at least a few hundred
Canon is unusual among digital camera companies, in that much of the software they provide with their cameras is private-labeled and available only from them. While unusual, this isn't at all a bad thing, because Canon's proprietary software is very functional. The overall suite of applications favors the Windows platform somewhat, but all important capabilities are available on the Mac as well (excepting only the slide-show upload function). Standard applications bundled with the PowerShot A5 include Adobe's PhotoDeluxe version 2.0 (Mac and Windows), and ULead's PhotoImpact 4.0 (Windows only). Canon's own products include the panorama and matrix-stitching program PhotoStitch (version 2.1 for Windows, 2.0 for the Mac); an unusual "album" photo-organizer program called TimeTunnel (version 2.2 for Windows, 1.6 for the Mac); SlideShow Maker (Windows only), an application for assembling slide shows to upload back to the camera for playback via the video output; and Zoom Browser (Windows only), an enhanced image organizer/viewer/downloader application. Also provided are version 2.2 of Canon's Photoshop(tm) plug-in for the Mac, and version 2.2 of their TWAIN driver for Windows systems.
We have to admit that we haven't played extensively with the A5's software, due to the extremely short time we had the system in-house. (Our testing was conducted very early in the A5's product cycle, when there were only 6 evaluation units in the US, so the we had to get everything done in a couple of days.) In our admittedly limited testing though, we found the PhotoStitch software to work quite well, although as with most such applications, a tripod is really a requirement, even with the help of the camera's stitch assist mode.
On other fronts, "TimeTunnel" is an interesting concept, deriving
its name in which images are presented as thumbnails arranged spatially according
to when the original image was taken. This is an interesting approach that makes
sense conceptually, but we frankly found it more confusing than useful. We unfortunately
had only very limited contact with Zoom Browser, and none at all with Slide
As with all Imaging Resource camera tests, we encourage you to let your own eyes be the judge of how well the devices performed: Explore the links at the bottom of this page, to see how well the PowerShot A5 performed, and how its images compare to other cameras you may be considering buying.
Overall, we were consistently impressed with the image quality of the A5: We predict that this will be a very successful camera, as it combines appealing ergonomics and a strong feature set with absolutely first-rate imaging.
As with virtually every digital point & shoot camera we've tested, we found the A5's viewfinder slightly inaccurate: The area shown in the viewfinder is slightly smaller than that captured by the sensor. The LCD screen is ever so slightly more accurate, displaying a tiny amount more image area than does the optical viewfinder. Both LCD and optical viewfinders are slightly biased toward the top of the scene, meaning that your images will end up offset downward by 2-3% of the picture height. We're really nit-picking here though, as both LCD and optical viewfinders on the PowerShot A5 are among the most accurate we've tested.
Using the "WG-18" ISO test standard, the PowerShot A5's visual resolution measured a very good ~550 line pairs per picture height in both the vertical and horizontal directions, although the vertical resolution showed a slight advantage. (Whenever we can dig out from under the load of cameras waiting for us to test, we'll post an article elsewhere on the site explaining image resolution, and this new international standard for resolution measurement.)
In real picture-taking situations, the PowerShot A5 proved itself a superb performer, rendering good detail and excellent color in all conditions. (Look at the colors of the flowers in the outdoor portrait shot, the excellent skin tones in the "musicians" image, and the well-balanced color in the house image.) You can get a good idea of the camera's detail-handling capability by looking at the standard house image. The "Davebox" test image reveals slightly under-saturated colors, but very good tonal rendition, with detail preserved in both moderate highlights and shadows. (Notice that almost every swatch of the long vertical grayscale wedge is visible, and that the delicate pastels in the Q60 target are preserved down to row "C.")
The PowerShot A5's macro capability was especially impressive for a non-zoom-lens
camera: At its closest working distance of 3.5 inches (8.9 cm) (!) it captured
an area of 2.4 x 3.2 inches (6.2 x 8.2 cm). (The small brooch in the "macro"
test shot is about 1.05 (27mm) wide.) While not approaching the "microscopic"
macro capabilities of some zoom-equipped cameras, the A5 is an absolutely stellar
performer in this area: If you need high-quality macro images at an affordable
price, this alone could swing you to the PowerShot A5.
We found the Canon PowerShot A5 to be an exceptionally appealing digital camera. It offers very good image quality in an uncommonly compact package, with a very rugged feel. It provides exceptional macro capability, as well as some of the best low-light performance we've seen to date. (This article was written in mid-May, 1998.) Nice touches include the standard-equipment NiMH battery pack and charger, and the inclusion of the relatively large 8 MB CF memory card. Overall, this would be an excellent choice for anyone looking for good image quality in a fixed focal-length digital camera at an attractive price point. (It's initial "street price" is projected at $699.)
Reader Sample Images!
Do you have a PowerShot A5 camera? If you'll post an album of your samples on one of the photo-sharing services and email us at firstname.lastname@example.org, we'll list the album here for others to see!
- Aaron Rabinowitz's A5 Album (Here's Aaron's, where's yours?)
Questions, comments or controversy on this article? Click this link to see what other Imaging Resource readers have had to say about Canon PowerShot A5, or add comments of your own!
1 $300 Adorama Gift Certificate
2 $200 Adorama Gift Certificate
3 $100 Adorama Gift Certificate