A note from Mike Tomkins, News Editor and sometime Gallery
Photographer Extraordinaire: When Dave first received the
SD10, I offered to lend a hand with the gallery photographs because I
wanted to see how the camera handled and what it could do. The original
SD9 was an interesting model, but not one I felt I could consider for
myself because I do like long-exposure / night photography and didn't
feel I could live with the shutter and ISO limitations. The SD10 aims
to solve these, and the allure of the Foveon sensor attracted me.
Over a couple of days, I took some pictures at several locations around
the Atlanta area which I think are quite pleasing. I tried where possible
to choose subjects that I felt would challenge the SD10 - for example
shooting at a fairly high ISO in the low light conditions of the Fuqua
Orchid Center at the Atlanta Botanical Gardens. The images can speak for
themselves, but I found the SD10 a rather well-behaved camera for the
most part, the only particular difficulty I had being that of a rather
inconsistent white balance performance. More on that later, though - for
now, enjoy the gallery!
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG09959s.jpg
YIMG09959adj.jpg
Size
3785.5 KB
3980.7 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/200
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
0.0
Contrast
N/A
+0.5
Shadow
N/A
-0.8
Highlight
N/A
-0.2
Saturation
N/A
+0.2
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
3M+8Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG09964s.jpg
YIMG09964adj.jpg
Size
2506.4 KB
2560.4 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
+0.7
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/250
Aperture Value
F4.5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
0.0
Contrast
N/A
+0.5
Shadow
N/A
-0.8
Highlight
N/A
-0.5
Saturation
N/A
+0.2
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.2
Color Adjustment
N/A
1M+5Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG09977s.jpg
YIMG09977adj.jpg
Size
2754.2 KB
2940.3 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/200
Aperture Value
F7.1
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
29mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
0.0
Contrast
N/A
+0.4
Shadow
N/A
-0.5
Highlight
N/A
-0.4
Saturation
N/A
0.0
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.2
Color Adjustment
N/A
1M+4Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG09983s.jpg
YIMG09983adj.jpg
Size
3420.4 KB
3636.5 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/250
Aperture Value
F6.3
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.2
Contrast
N/A
-0.1
Shadow
N/A
-0.7
Highlight
N/A
-0.7
Saturation
N/A
+0.4
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.1
Color Adjustment
N/A
1M+1Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10004s.jpg
YIMG10004adj.jpg
Size
3565.8 KB
3947.8 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/250
Aperture Value
F8
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
20mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
0.0
Contrast
N/A
+0.3
Shadow
N/A
-0.4
Highlight
N/A
+0.2
Saturation
N/A
+0.1
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
2Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10017s.jpg
YIMG10017adj.jpg
Size
3034.8 KB
3238.9 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/320
Aperture Value
F8
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.4
Contrast
N/A
+0.3
Shadow
N/A
-0.3
Highlight
N/A
+0.1
Saturation
N/A
+0.1
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
1Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10020s.jpg
YIMG10020adj.jpg
Size
3512.9 KB
3699.9 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/200
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.1
Contrast
N/A
+0.5
Shadow
N/A
-0.3
Highlight
N/A
-0.6
Saturation
N/A
-0.1
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.6
Color Adjustment
N/A
1Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10028s.jpg
YIMG10028adj.jpg
Size
2530.2 KB
2709.8 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
+0.7
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/400
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.6
Contrast
N/A
0.0
Shadow
N/A
-0.3
Highlight
N/A
+0.2
Saturation
N/A
+0.3
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
1C+1M
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10030s.jpg
YIMG10030adj.jpg
Size
2784.1 KB
3066.7 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
100
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/400
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
+0.4
Contrast
N/A
+0.4
Shadow
N/A
-0.5
Highlight
N/A
-0.3
Saturation
N/A
-0.1
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.0
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.5
Color Adjustment
N/A
1M+3Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10036s.jpg
YIMG10036adj.jpg
Size
2616.6 KB
3017.9 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/250
Aperture Value
F4.5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
+0.3
Contrast
N/A
-0.3
Shadow
N/A
-0.1
Highlight
N/A
0.0
Saturation
N/A
+0.3
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
1C+2Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10047s.jpg
YIMG10047adj.jpg
Size
2241.5 KB
2119.1KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/320
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
+0.0
Contrast
N/A
-0.2
Shadow
N/A
+0.5
Highlight
N/A
+0.3
Saturation
N/A
+0.5
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.5
Color Adjustment
N/A
1Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10050s.jpg
YIMG10050adj.jpg
Size
3047.3 KB
3310.7 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/250
Aperture Value
F5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
105mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-1.0
Contrast
N/A
+0.2
Shadow
N/A
+0.3
Highlight
N/A
-0.7
Saturation
N/A
+0.5
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+1.0
Color Adjustment
N/A
6C+3Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10051s.jpg
YIMG10051adj.jpg
Size
2667.8 KB
2462.5 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/160
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
40mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
0.0
Contrast
N/A
-0.2
Shadow
N/A
+0.5
Highlight
N/A
-0.1
Saturation
N/A
+0.5
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.5
Color Adjustment
N/A
1Y
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10056s.jpg
YIMG10056adj.jpg
Size
3451.7 KB
3488.2 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/125
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
20mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.5
Contrast
N/A
-0.7
Shadow
N/A
-0.2
Highlight
N/A
+0.2
Saturation
N/A
+0.6
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.3
Color Adjustment
N/A
1C+5M
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10066s.jpg
YIMG10066adj.jpg
Size
2768.5 KB
2521.7 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/160
Aperture Value
F5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.1
Contrast
N/A
-0.2
Shadow
N/A
+0.2
Highlight
N/A
-0.3
Saturation
N/A
+0.2
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.4
Color Adjustment
N/A
1C
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10069s.jpg
YIMG10069adj.jpg
Size
2999.3 KB
3341.5 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/160
Aperture Value
F5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
+0.3
Contrast
N/A
-0.4
Shadow
N/A
-0.1
Highlight
N/A
-0.4
Saturation
N/A
+0.4
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
+0.2
Color Adjustment
N/A
3C+1M
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10072s.jpg
YIMG10072adj.jpg
Size
2622.2 KB
2228.4 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
-0.7
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/200
Aperture Value
F5.6
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
+0.1
Contrast
N/A
-0.5
Shadow
N/A
+0.2
Highlight
N/A
-1.2
Saturation
N/A
+0.4
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
-0.8
Color Adjustment
N/A
0
Raw
Adjusted
Filename
YIMG10080s.jpg
YIMG10080adj.jpg
Size
2973.1 KB
2895.4 KB
Camera Settings
Exp. Mode
Program
Exp. Comp.
0
ISO Setting
800
White Balance
Auto
Flash
Off
Shutter Speed
1/125
Aperture Value
F4.5
Metering Mode
Multi
Focus Setting
AF-S
Focal Length
50mm
Resolution
High
Drive Mode
Single
Photo
Pro Settings
Exposure
N/A
-0.1
Contrast
N/A
-0.4
Shadow
N/A
-0.7
Highlight
N/A
-0.3
Saturation
N/A
+0.2
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
N/A
0.0
Color Adjustment
N/A
0
In my introduction, I noted that I had some difficulty with inconsistent
white balance from our near-production level SD10 digital SLR. Below,
I've included a comparison to demonstrate what I mean by this (and also,
to show that whilst perhaps frustrating, the problem isn't insurmountable
and can be corrected fairly well in the excellent Sigma Photo Pro software).
My general manner of shooting is to bracket like crazy - meaning that
I'm forever taking multiple photos of the same subjects at intervals of
only a few seconds apart. Since the SD10 white balance can be adjusted
after-the-fact in Photo Pro, I left the camera set to Auto white balance
- and on my return to the office, I noticed quite a few instances of photos
taken with near-identical settings and framing yielding vastly different
white balance adjustments.
For those of you interested in the settings for the original photos,
since there's no easy way to fit them into the complex table below, both
were taken as high resolution files at a focal length of 105mm in Program
AE mode at ISO 800, using auto white balance, multi metering, single AF
and Drive modes. Courtesy of the auto exposure bracketing feature on the
camera, the -0.7EV file was 1/250 second at F4.5, whilst the 0EV file
was 1/200 second at F4. This was the only setting difference on the camera
between these frames, which were taken with near-identical framing and
lighting within four seconds of each other.
-0.7
EV
0.0
EV
Raw
versions
Filename
YIMG10039s.jpg
YIMG10041s.jpg
Size
2790.3 KB
3052.9 KB
Adjusted
versions
Filename
YIMG10039adj.jpg
YIMG10041adj.jpg
Size
3103.3 KB
3333.1 KB
Photo
Pro Settings (for adjusted versions)
Exposure
0.0
-0.4
Contrast
+0.5
+0.5
Shadow
-0.2
-0.3
Highlight
-0.3
+0.0
Saturation
0.0
-0.1
Sharpness
+0.5
+0.5
X3 Fill Light
+0.4
+0.1
Color Adjustment
4C+1Y
1M+33Y (!)
Also, I've included two further photos that show common difficulties
photographers come up against, and show off how Photo Pro can easily (in
a matter of seconds) correct common problems. Both photos suffer from
lens flare even though I use lens hoods religiously - mostly because I
was shooting late in the day and with a very bright afternoon sun glaring
low in the sky. The picture of the thatched roof at the Atlanta Zoo is
the worst case, and I was surprised by how well it cleaned up in Photo
Pro. The building photo taken at Underground Atlanta, meanwhile, showed
a lesser degree of flare but demonstrated nicely how Foveon's new X3 Fill
Light filter can bring a photo back to life that would otherwise end up
being discarded. All in all, I think Photo Pro is one of the biggest reasons
to consider buying the SD10. I'll be writing a commentary on the program
shortly (I'd hoped to do so today, but time overtook me!) - so check our
review soon for my more detailed thoughts...