Digital Camera Home > Digital Camera Reviews > Nikon Digital Cameras > Nikon D70S

Nikon D70S

Nikon updates its midrange SLR with improved focusing, larger LCD, a new menu interface, and more.

<<Flash :(Previous) | (Next): Operation and User Interface>>

Page 10:Shutter Lag / Cycle Times

Review First Posted: 06/30/2005

Shutter Lag / Cycle Times

When you press the shutter release on a camera, there's usually a lag time before the shutter actually fires. This time allows the autofocus and autoexposure mechanisms time to do their work and can amount to a fairly long delay in some situations. Since this number is rarely reported on (and even less often reported accurately), and can significantly affect the picture taking experience, I now routinely measure it, using a custom test system I built for the purpose, accurate to 0.001 second.

Nikon D70s Timings
Operation
Time
(secs)
Notes
Power On -> First shot
~0.4
Hold down the shutter button while turning on the power, and there's only a slight delay. Marginally slower than the D70? Hard to tell, both are so fast that they're hard to measure.
Shutdown
0 - 3
First time is simple power-off, second time is worst-case buffer-clearing time, with a Lexar 80x CF card. Pretty darned fast, faster than the original D70.
Play to Record, first shot
~0.1
Time until first shot is captured. Nearly instantaneous.
Record to play
0.8 / 0.2
First time is that required to display a large/fine file immediately after capture, second time is that needed to display a large/fine file that has already been processed and stored on the memory card. Very fast.
Shutter lag, full autofocus
0.29
Very fast, a measurable improvement over the D70. (D70 tested at 0.34 second in same configuration.)

Shutter lag, continuous autofocus

0.135
Excellent speed.
Shutter lag, manual focus
0.134
Quite fast, just a shade quicker than the 0.155 second of the original D70.
Shutter lag, prefocus
0.106
Time to capture, after half-pressing shutter button. Very fast, again slightly faster than the D70's 0.124 second.
Shutter lag, manual focus, internal flash enabled 0.151 The metering pre-flash of the internal flash head seems to introduce only a very slight increase in shutter lag, about 16 milliseconds or so. (0.016 second.)
Shutter lag, manual focus, external wireless flash enabled 0.327 Shutter lag does increase when using the Nikon Wireless Lighting system, due to the time required for the camera and remote flashes to communicate with each other. Still, roughly 0.3 second isn't at all bad, particularly considering the capabilities it gives you.
Cycle Time, RAW

0.67

Times are averages. Shoots four frames at this pace, then slows to 1.15 seconds per shot. Buffer clears in 3 seconds with Lexar 80x CF card. (Expect slower clearing with slower cards.) Four shot buffer beats the two shots the original D70 managed.
Cycle Time, max/min resolution JPEGs 0.67
(1.5 fps)
Times are averages. Cycle time is the same for large/fine files or "TV" size images. Camera finishes writing to the card in 2 seconds for large/fine images, almost immediately for lowest resolution. Very slightly slower than the D70, the buffer limit seems to be about 18-19 large/fine images when shooting in single-shot mode.
Cycle Time, continuous mode, RAW

0.34
(2.9 fps)

Times are averages. Shoots three frames at this pace, then slows to 1.15 seconds per shot. Buffer clears in 2 seconds with Lexar 80x card. Original D70 shot two frames, then dropped to 1.65 second/frame. (With Lexar 40x card.)
Cycle Time, continuous mode, JPEG, Noise Reduction OFF 0.33
(3.05 fps)

Buffer Full:
0.51
(1.96 fps)
The D70S takes good advantage of fast memory cards, as it manages long runs of shots in continuous mode, slows only slightly once the buffer is full, and clears the buffer quickly when you stop shooting. With a Lexar 1GB 80x CF card, the D70S shot just over 3 frames/second for 15 large/fine images before having to slow to wait for the memory card. With the fast card though, it managed almost 2 frames/second until the card filled. The buffer cleared 7 seconds after we stopped shooting.

By contrast, with an old/slow CF card (a Kensington 64MB from several years ago), the camera managed only 9 frames at full speed, then slowed to 3.2 seconds/frame.
Cycle Time, continuous mode, max/min resolution JPEGs, Noise Reduction ON 0.66
(1.5 fps)
Like the D70 before it, there's a stiff speed penalty if you leave the Noise Reduction enabled, even if you're shooting at shutter speeds that shouldn't require any noise reduction to be applied to the images. The moral is to leave NR off unless you specifically need it.

(These times are averages. Cycle time is the same for large/fine files or "TV" size images. No apparent buffer limit (with a Lexar 80x card), camera stops writing to the card after 2 seconds for large/fine images, almost immediately for lowest resolution.)

Along with its other excellent features, the D70S is quite fast and responsive. Most impressive of course, is its continuous-mode speed and very long burst lengths (with sufficiently fast memory cards). With many cameras in the past, really fast memory cards often made a difference only in buffer-clearing speed, not so much in burst length or shot to shot cycle time. With the D70S and its predecessor the D70 though, we finally have cameras that can really take advantage of fast cards. With a card offering a write speed rating of 9MB/second or so, it can actually shoot at 3 frames/second (fps) in large/normal mode without stopping, until the memory card is filled. Even with slightly slower cards in the range of 24-40x, it shows surprisingly long burst capability and surprisingly fast post-buffer-fill speed. Shooting with either an 80x Lexar card or an Ultra II SanDisk card, I found that I could manage 15 large/fine JPEGs before the speed dropped below the 3 fps maximum rate (3.05 fps by actual measurement), and even then, the decrease in performance was very modest, with the frame rate dropping only to about 2.0 fps. (A little lower than that with the SanDisk Ultra II, with more shot to shot variation.)

To make the most of the D70S though, you really do want to have as fast a memory card as you can afford. When I put an ancient (1x speed?) 64 MB memory card in the D70S, its buffer depth in continuous mode dropped to 9 frames, and the post-buffer-fill cycle time stretched to 3.2 seconds per shot.(!) Take my advice, and make the small incremental investment to purchase a good, fast card to use with your D70S, rather than pinching a few pennies to get a bargain-basement one. It's an accessory that you'll be living with for a long time, and it can make a huge impact on the camera's responsiveness.

Startup time is another area where the D70S does really well. While we reported its startup delay above as being 0.4 second, it's actually pretty hard to come up with a consistent measurement for it, it's that fast. (Really, faster than our reflexes on the timer button.) Bottom line, the D70S can get ready to shoot a picture at least as fast as you can. (Editor Mike Tomkins may have figured out how the D70S manages to start up so quickly: It never entirely powers down! Here's what he found, in his own words:

It seems to me that the reason for this is that even when switched "off", the D70S is partly powered on. To confirm it for yourself, set the camera to manual everything, switch it off, remove the battery - then switch it on, and reinsert the battery while holding the shutter button down. You needn't shut the battery door, just pushing the battery all the way in is enough. If you do this, it takes - subjective guess - around 1 to 1.5 seconds to start up and capture a photo. Which is not to knock it at all, because it works - startup feels incredibly fast, and they've apparently managed to keep power consumption in this partly alive state VERY low since it will happily stay like this for days with no noticeable drain.

Shutter response was a little faster than the original D70, although not dramatically so. Manual-focus and pre-focus lag times were 0.134 and 0.106 seconds, respectively. Here's a brief table, comparing the performance of the D70S with that of the original D70, the Digital Rebel, the Digital Rebel XT, and Canon's EOS-20D:

d-SLR Timing Performance
Parameter Nikon D70S Nikon D70 Canon Digital Rebel Canon Digital Rebel XT Canon
EOS-20D
Startup ~0.4 "Instant" 3.09 ~0.25 ~0.25
AF Lag 0.29 0.34-0.49 0.25-0.28 0.20-0.24 0.16
Prefocus Lag 0.106 0.124 0.142 0.095 0.077
Cycle Time 0.33
(3.05 fps)
0.34
(2.92 fps)
0.40
(2.50 fps)
0.36
(2.78 fps)
0.21
(4.76 fps)
Buffer Depth
(w/fast card)
15 21 4 13 21-31

Overall, the four lower-end cameras come in fairly close to each other with only the more expensive Canon EOS 20D performing notably faster. While the original D70 was dramatically ahead of the competing Canon Digital Rebel across the board, Canon has significantly narrowed the gap in their new Digital Rebel XT. Overall, the impact of the D70S's buffer capacity was subtle but dramatic. (If that's not an oxymoron.) It wasn't so much something that I was that much aware of while I was shooting, but rather that I gradually became aware that I never had to wait for the camera when was shooting in JPEG mode.

 

 

Reader Comments! --> Visit our discussion forum for the Nikon D70S!



<<Flash | Operation and User Interface>>

Follow Imaging Resource: