Sony A33 Review
|Full model name:||Sony Alpha SLT-A33|
(23.7mm x 15.6mm)
|Viewfinder:||EVF / LCD|
|Native ISO:||100 - 12,800|
|Extended ISO:||100 - 25,600|
|Shutter:||1/4000 - 30 sec|
|Max Aperture:||3.5 (kit lens)|
4.9 x 3.6 x 3.3 in.
(124 x 92 x 85 mm)
includes batteries, kit lens
|Full specs:||Sony A33 specifications|
4.5 out of 5.0
Sony Alpha SLT-A33 Overview
Reviewed by Dave Etchells, Mike Tomkins, Shawn Barnett, and Zig Weidelich
Preview Posted: 08/24/2010
Updated to Full Review: 10/29/2010
Just three months after launching the NEX-3 and NEX-5 single-lens direct-view (SLD) cameras, Sony offers up yet another interchangeable lens alternative to the traditional DSLR, with the Alpha SLT-A33, and its closely-related sibling the SLT-A55. Instead of being mirrorless, the new digital cameras employ a "translucent mirror," more commonly known as a pellicle mirror. This advanced translucent mirror remains fixed in place during operation, allowing most of the light to reach the imaging sensor, while a small percentage is reflected to a dedicated autofocus sensor.
It's what this high technology allows that's so exciting: real-time, phase-detect autofocus while firing off up to seven 14-megapixel frames per second in the A33, and ten 16-megapixel images per second in the A55. Few other large-sensor cameras offer frame rates this fast. DSLRs rivalling the A33's speed are available for a little over $1,500, while only professional cameras that cost around $5,000 can match the speed of the A55 -- and they're still not capable of real-time autofocus between shots like the new Sony Alpha SLT cameras. Real-time phase-detect autofocus is also constantly available in Movie mode, something no current SLR can achieve.
While the translucent mirror design isn't quite as space-efficient as the mirrorless design of an SLD camera, it's still smaller than that of a traditional SLR, most of which need to provide room for the mirror to swing upward before image capture can commence. That translates to an uncommonly compact body by SLR standards, although it's still a bit larger than an SLD, especially in terms of body thickness. Unlike SLD cameras, though, the Sony SLT cameras all accept the entire line of standard Alpha-mount lenses, a significant advantage if you already own a large collection of Alpha-mount glass.
Since the translucent mirror only reflects enough light to provide for the autofocus sensor, not an optical viewfinder as most pellicle designs permit, Sony has adopted full-time live view in the Alpha A33 and A55. In place of the optical viewfinder from a traditional SLR, the SLT cameras have an electronic viewfinder with 1,152,000 dot resolution. The EVF LCD is time-multiplexed -- that is to say, it shows each color in sequence at every pixel location, rather than the separate, adjacent color dots of most electronic viewfinders. This makes it harder to distinguish individual pixels. The Sony SLT-series cameras also sport a wide-aspect 3-inch LCD with 921,600-dot resolution. Taking full advantage of the camera's full-time live view shooting, the super-slim LCD tilts 180 degrees vertically, and swivels 270 degrees for easy viewing from most any angle. The cameras also include TruBlack technology borrowed from Sony's picture frames.
Several hot features were brought over from Sony's NEX and Cyber-shot digital cameras, including Sweep Panorama, 3D Sweep Panorama, Auto High-Dynamic Range, and Handheld Twilight modes, each of which strategically combine and align several images into one seamless shot. It's pretty impressive stuff. As if that weren't enough, Sony has added an extra mode for the SLT-series cameras -- Multi-Frame NR -- which operates similarly to the handheld twilight mode, but allows the ISO sensitivity to be specified.
The Sony Alpha A33 lacks one feature found in the A55V (the only version of the A55 that's sold in the US market) -- a built-in GPS receiver. It's still possible to geotag images and movies from the A33, but doing so will rely on an external GPS logging device and PC software that can backtrack to calculate the location at which images and movies were shot -- not nearly as seamless a solution as the A55V's ability to geotag images and movies straight out of the box.
The Sony Alpha A33 accepts both Memory Stick Pro Duo / Pro-HG Duo, and SD / SDHC / SDXC media, and is powered by an InfoLithium battery pack.
The Sony A33 ships in the US market from mid-October 2010, with pricing of US$750 for the camera body and an 18-55mm kit lens, or $650 for the body only package.
Sony Alpha A33 User Report
by Dave Etchells, Mike Tomkins, and Shawn Barnett
Look and feel. Although it lacks the reflex mirror of an SLR, having replaced it with a fixed translucent mirror, the basic shape of the Sony SLT-A33 still follows that of a traditional SLR fairly closely. That's because, since it accepts the same Alpha lenses as Sony's DSLRs, the Sony A33 also has to accommodate the same backfocus distance, which is one of the main contributors to the size -- and especially, the depth -- of an SLR camera. Removing the reflex mirror still provides potential for space and weight savings, and Sony has taken good advantage of this. Most obviously, the drive mechanism that raises and lowers the reflex mirror in a traditional SLR isn't needed. The translucent mirror design also provides other opportunities to optimize component placement. As one example of this, Sony has increased the angle of the translucent mirror, so that instead of directing light directly upward at a 90 degree angle as it would for a viewfinder prism, it is actually angled upward and slightly forward, allowing the autofocus sensor to be moved forward, providing more room for the electronic viewfinder assembly directly to the rear.
The net result is that, while the Sony Alpha A33 is a fair bit thicker front-to-back than single-lens direct-view (SLD) cameras, which can do away with the bulky mirror box entirely, it's still an exceptionally small camera by SLR standards. If the handgrip depth is ignored, the Sony A33 is actually just a little smaller than the smallest digital SLR to date, the Olympus E-420. Unlike the smallest SLD cameras, the A33 still includes a built-in electronic viewfinder -- and for those SLDs that can accept an optional electronic viewfinder, much of their size advantage over Sony's SLT-series models is erased once it's installed. Sony's A33 thus occupies a comfortable middle ground, sacrificing little of the versatility of a traditional SLR, yet bringing a worthwhile advantage in portability.
While not quite as light as the Olympus E-420, which lacks an in-body image stabilization mechanism, the Sony Alpha SLT-A33 is certainly in the same ballpark. The A33 weighs 17.3 ounces (1.08 pounds, 492g), with battery and flash card (but no lens), while the Olympus E-420 weighs 15.7 ounces (0.98 pounds, 445g) loaded but without a lens. The lightest SLD, Sony's NEX-5, weighs just 17.7 ounces (1.1 pounds, 502g) loaded and with its kit lens attached -- just 0.4 ounces more than the A33 body without a lens.
Thanks to its smaller body, and especially their reduced height due to the lack of a pentaprism or pentamirror assembly, the Sony A33 looks rather aggressive, with the popup flash housing hunched low over the top of the lens barrel. A soft, rubber pad surrounds most of the handgrip, and wraps around to the rear of the camera to cover a small, contoured thumb grip area as well.
Due to its diminutive stature, most photographers will find that the grip only accommodates two fingers, with the index finger resting on the shutter release button above, and the little finger curling beneath the bottom of the camera. This might seem a little crowded, but with the light, plastic-bodied 18-55mm kit lens, handling is nonetheless good, with the combination feeling extremely well balanced. Using larger, heavier lenses, the grip size is too tiring for single-handed shooting, so the photographer's left hand will need to serve double duty, adjusting zoom or focus while simultaneously taking up the weight of the lens itself.
Centered to the right of the lens in the photo above is the lens release button, while the depth-of-field preview button is positioned snugly at the bottom left corner of the lens mount. A small plastic panel in the handgrip conceals the infrared remote control sensor at top, and the self-timer lamp beneath. Directly beneath the shutter button and power switch is the control dial, used to make adjustments to exposure and variables and menu options.
From the top of the Sony Alpha A33 camera body, you can just see the stereo microphones, located on either side of the flash hot shoe on the sides of the viewfinder / popup flash housing, as well as the three hole grille the speaker (above the Finder/LCD button). At the top of the handgrip is the popular combination of a shutter button surrounded by a power switch, making it easy to quickly power on the camera and snap a picture with one finger. The Finder / LCD button allows the A33 to be manually switched between shooting with the electronic viewfinder or the rear LCD panel. Upper right of this is a D-Range button that provides access to Dynamic Range Optimizer and High Dynamic Range shooting options.
The Mode dial on the left shoulder is used to select the camera's operating mode. An angled panel allows you to view four buttons from either the rear or above: Menu, Movie, Exposure Compensation, and Auto-exposure Lock buttons.
You can also see the top of the mechanism for the tilt / swivel LCD panel, peeking out on either side of the electronic viewfinder. The viewfinder itself projects quite a bit from the rear of the camera, a decision that was apparently necessitated by the tight packaging of components in front, including the AF module, popup flash, hot shoe, and microphones.
When using the Sony A33 with a neckstrap and particularly light lens, this might cause it to bump against your body, but with even moderately heavy lenses the camera will turn face-down even though this doesn't match the strap mount alignment, and this won't be an issue. A positive side-effect of the EVF positioning is that it makes it easier to keep your nose from smudging the LCD panel. Given the relatively tight eyepoint of the electronic viewfinder, the projection also helps prevent the photographer having to jam the camera to their face to see the entire viewfinder display.
Tilt / swivel LCD. At the rear, the 3-inch LCD dominates much of the available real-estate, and its tilt/swivel mechanism -- appearing for the first time in an Alpha camera -- can be clearly seen. The display tilts down 180 degrees and then swivels 270 degrees, allowing it to face any direction except to the front right (handgrip) quadrant. The design not only allows easy framing of high- and low-angle shots, but also allows subjects in front of the lens to see themselves -- but only when somebody's available to hold the camera. Since the display tilts downwards, it will be blocked from view when mounted on a tripod, and can't be extended beyond the 90-degree position with the camera placed on a flat surface, so the only way to use it for self-portraits is to hold the camera at arm's length. It can also be difficult to deploy and use with the camera mounted on a tripod.
On the positive side, the mechanism does allow the LCD to be folded facing inwards, providing some degree of protection against minor knocks and smudges when traveling and when you're content to use the EVF instead. The Xtra Fine LCD panel has a 921,600-dot resolution. The display also uses Sony's TruBlack technology, which couples a reinforced glass cover plate with anti-reflective film, and a resin filling that removes the air gap beneath the cover plate, which the company says improves contrast and reduces glare under harsh sunlight.
Thanks again to the relatively short stature of the Sony A33, the remainder of the rear-panel controls are rather difficult to reach when shooting single-handed, even with the relatively light kit lens attached. There are only a few buttons, Function, Playback, and Delete, plus a four-way controller with a central OK button. This isn't an issue if shooting two-handed, but you do have to change your grip fairly substantially to reach any further than the top quadrant of the four-way controller. With real-estate at a premium, Sony has only provided markings on the controller for the alternate functions offered during shooting (and in the case of the Up / Display button, during playback).
Translucent (pellicle) mirror. Undoubtedly the biggest story of the Sony SLT-series cameras is their use of a translucent mirror. Also known as pellicle mirror, this works by allowing most light to pass through to the imaging surface beneath, while a small portion is reflected for other purposes. Sony is not the first camera manufacturer to use a translucent mirror in an SLR-style camera, with the manual focus Canon Pellix film camera from 1965 taking that credit. The Pellix was followed by a handful of other pellicle mirror-based SLRs from Canon, Nikon, and Mamiya, largely designed for professional photographers, and manufactured in very limited production runs. It wasn't until 1989's Canon EOS RT that the first autofocus pellicle camera was released, followed by the EOS-1N RS in 1995. Fifteen years later, Sony has become the first company to resurrect the pellicle mirror for use in an interchangeable lens digital camera.
Full-time autofocus. There are several advantages to the use of a translucent mirror in place of a traditional single-lens reflex mirror mechanism. The Sony Alpha A33 uses the design to allow it to simultaneously provide a live view feed with full-time phase detection autofocus. Most of the light is transmitted to the image sensor, while a smaller portion is delivered to the phase detection AF sensor, where it can be used to perform focus adjustments -- even during live view, high-speed shooting, and movie recording.
While contrast-detection AF systems these days are much faster than they used to be, phase-detection AF generally still has the edge in terms of outright speed. It also involves less hunting around the point of focus, since phase-detection systems can determine both the focus direction and the required adjustment. On the flip side, though, contrast-detection systems generally offer more precise focusing, since the image sensor itself is responsible for confirming the point of focus, without any reliance on the lens's focus drive and AF sensor alignment being perfectly in spec.
The Sony A33 adopts a newly developed phase-detection autofocus sensor and lens module with 15 points, of which three are cross-type. AF points can be selected automatically or manually, and both predictive control (tracking) and face detection are included, although the cameras can only focus on detected faces if they fall under a phase detection point. Autofocus working range is -1 EV to +18 EV (at ISO 100 equivalent), and there's no dedicated AF assist lamp, with the A33 relying on low-power bursts of internal flash or an external strobe's assist lamp for focusing in low light.
Continuous shooting. As well as allowing full-time AF during live view and movie capture, the translucent mirror design of the Sony Alpha A33 brings another important advantage. During burst shooting with continuous autofocus, a traditional SLR has to drop its mirror between each frame, wait just long enough for any mirror vibration to settle, perform the AF measurement, and then raise the mirror again so that the next frame can be captured. Using a pellicle mirror, there's no reflex mirror to raise, and so the only delay required is to wait for the lens aperture to open after the exposure has been completed. For even swifter burst shooting, the aperture can be locked at either F3.5, or the maximum aperture of the lens, whichever is smaller, removing the delay required to set and reset the aperture to allow focusing between shots. The Sony A33 offers burst shooting at up to six frames per second ordinarily, but with the aperture locked in Continuous Priority AE shoots even faster, providing a very respectable seven frames per second. (Its sibling, the A55, is even swifter with a whopping ten frames per second in Continuous Priority AE mode.) Sony also notes that, for like framerates, the autofocus system in the Alpha A33 can be active for a greater proportion of the time compared to a traditional SLR, providing more data from which to make AF tracking predictions.
Burst depth for the Sony A33 is seven Raw or Raw+JPEG frames, and 16 Fine or 20 Standard JPEG frames in a burst. That's quite a bit less than the A55, which can capture twenty Raw or Raw+JPEG frames, while JPEG shooters can expect 35 Fine or 39 Standard-compression frames, but in our experience, the Sony A33 makes up for this deficit somewhat by clearing its buffer much faster. This means that although the A55 will get you more shots in a burst, the A33 will be ready to start another burst much sooner.
One quirk of the design of the Sony A33 (and shared by the A55) unfortunately conspires to make this high-speed burst shooting somewhat harder to use than would otherwise be the case. For both the ultra-speedy Continuous Priority AE mode, and the six frames per second Continuous Advance Hi mode, the live view isn't shown on the viewfinder or LCD panel. Instead, the A33 shows the previously captured image. This makes it harder to follow fast-moving action, since rather than seeing what's you're trying to frame, you're effectively seeing a static slideshow of what happened around a tenth of a second earlier. This problem, incidentally, is also found on all of the SLD's we've reviewed. The Continuous Advance Lo mode, which shoots at around 2.5 frames per second on the A33, does return to the live view between shots, but only briefly -- so it can still be a little hard to follow.
Image sensor and processor. Of course, the image sensor and processor are also an important part of the speed and image quality of the Sony A33. The Sony SLT-A33 has a newly developed Exmor APS HD CMOS sensor, which has a total resolution of 14.6 megapixels, and an effective resolution of 14.2 megapixels. That's just slightly below the 16.7 megapixel total resolution of the A55, which yields its effective resolution of 16.2 megapixels.
The new CMOS image sensor in the Sony A33 features on-chip column A/D conversion, which helps increase readout speed. It also includes the same on-chip analog and digital noise reduction that featured previously in the Sony A900. The Sony A33 also sports an updated BIONZ image processor, with reworked algorithms to allow its signature high-speed burst shooting, plus digital compositing and Full HD movie recording. The Sony Alpha A33 offers sensitivities ranging from ISO 100 to 12,800 equivalents, and can automatically select an ISO sensitivity between ISO 100 and 1,600 equivalents.
Alpha mount. The Sony A33 accepts Alpha-mount lenses from Sony, and is backward-compatible with older Minolta or Konica Minolta A-mount lenses, allowing use of a huge range of both current and historic glass. Compared to single-lens direct view cameras -- even Sony's own NEX series -- this will likely make the Sony A33 a much more attractive proposition for existing Alpha or A-mount photographers. While Alpha-mount lenses can be used on NEX cameras through a mount adapter, they lose their in-body SteadyShot capabilities, whereas the Sony A33 retains this capability with the same lenses. (In an earlier version of this review, we also called attention to the inability to autofocus using Alpha-mount lenses on NEX-series bodies, but this looks to be negated by a forthcoming update for the LA-EA1 mount adapter that will enable Alpha-mount AF on NEX bodies. We've not yet tested this update, and hence can't comment on how NEX and SLT-series cameras will compare in this area.) Sony rates the SteadyShot sensor shift mechanism in the Alpha A33 for between 2.5 and four stops of correction.
While we don't currently have details on the precise viewfinder type employed by the Sony A33 -- Sony describes it as a 0.46-inch diagonal (0.43-inch effective) Xtra Fine LCD Tru-Finder -- it clearly employs a time-multiplexed method to display red, green, and blue color information at every pixel location, suggesting it is likely a ferroelectric LCD. This differs from traditional LCD displays, which mostly create color information with a cluster of three adjacent red, green, and blue subpixels (commonly called 'dots'), for each pixel location. When compared to standard LCD electronic viewfinders, ferroelectric types bring both advantages and disadvantages. They've proven somewhat divisive in the past, due to their tendency to demonstrate RGB "rainbow" artifacts when you blink or move your eyes, or with fast-moving subjects. On the positive side, though, since each pixel provides full color, ferroelectric LCDs tend to look much smoother and more detailed than their traditional LCD siblings, with less obvious pixel structure. They also tend to have higher refresh rates, and indeed Sony specs the EVF used in the A33 as offering a 60Hz refresh rate. It's not surprising to see such a display adopted by Sony, since Konica Minolta -- the company Sony absorbed to create its DSLR division -- was a particular proponent of their use.
We're pleased to report that the EVF in the Sony A33 provides better dynamic range than most, and does a decent job of preserving highlight detail in high-contrast scenes. The slight distraction caused by the "rainbow" effect is relatively easy to ignore most of the time. Sony specs the EVF as having 1,440,000 dots, of which 1,152,000 are effective in the viewfinder display. We believe that the company is following precedent here, by reporting a dot count as if each pixel constituted three separate color dots, rather than being time-multiplexed. If that's the case, the actual pixel resolution would be 480,000 total pixels, of which 384,000 are effective in the final image.
It's a little unusual to see an effective pixel resolution for an electronic viewfinder, but we believe the reason effective resolution is some 20% lower than the EVF's actual pixel count is that Sony has selected an LCD with approximately a 4:3 aspect ratio, but are only using the central 16:9 aspect ratio swathe of the display. This is likely done both to match the rear-panel LCD display aspect, and also because even with this crop, the EVF already has a generous 1.1x magnification -- much higher than that of most APS-C DSLRs -- and a somewhat tight eyepoint of 19mm from the viewfinder eyepiece (18mm from the eyepiece frame). Were the whole display used, the eyepoint would fall uncomfortably low -- it's already just a little tight for eyeglass wearers. Thankfully, it includes an unusually wide -4 to +4 diopter adjustment range, better mitigating the tight eyepoint for those with eyeglass prescriptions inside this range. It also has a 100% field of view, and three step automatic / manual brightness control.
Translucent mirror (redux). As noted previously, adopting a translucent mirror design has allowed Sony important benefits in terms of autofocus, burst shooting, and body size, and conceivably the removal of one more mechanical component could improve camera reliability, as well. There's no such thing as a free lunch, though, and the translucent mirror design does have some clear disadvantages as compared to existing SLR and SLD designs. Perhaps most significantly, light entering the lens is shared between the autofocus and image sensors at a fixed ratio. In the Sony A33, about 70% of the light makes it to the imaging sensor, while 30% is reflected to the autofocus module. With a traditional SLR, all the incoming light arrives at the image sensor once the mirror is raised, and the same is true of an SLD camera whenever its shutter is open. With less light arriving at the sensor for an equivalent aperture, a translucent mirror camera must either lower its shutter speed, raise its sensitivity (and along with this, the levels of noise, or the amount processing to mitigate it), or some combination of both. An increase in sensor gain to compensate for the loss may explain why we see slightly higher noise levels from the A33 versus the A560, which share the same sensor.
Another potential issue of the translucent mirror design is that with an extra optical surface between the lens and the imager, flare could be increased, and image quality degraded, and indeed we've seen some evidence of this in predominantly dark shots containing bright point light sources, as described elsewhere in this review. There's also another surface for dust to adhere to, and while this would be too far from the image sensor to appear as distinct specks, it could further contribute to issues with flare and reduced contrast. While manual sensor cleaning will now be a familiar process for photographers used to shooting with a digital SLR, cleaning the pellicle mirror is a total unknown. The Sony A33 provides a cleaning mode allowing the sensor to be accessed, and the pellicle mirror itself can be manually raised to facilitate this, but Sony's documentation provides no advice on cleaning the pellicle mirror itself, simply noting that the surface of the mirror shouldn't be touched.
Exposure. The Sony A33 offers a selection of exposure modes commonplace on any DSLR, as well as several more unusual modes. These include Auto, Auto+ (Advanced Auto), Programmed AE, Aperture Priority, Shutter-speed Priority, Manual, Continuous Advance Priority AE, Sweep Panorama, Scene, and Flash Off modes. The Advanced Auto mode acts much like a regular Auto mode, taking control of most settings, but differs from the standard Auto mode in that it can also access some of Sony's more unique multi-shot modes, such as Handheld Twilight and High Dynamic Range. Continuous Advance Priority AE increases the maximum burst shooting speed as compared to the standard Continuous Advance modes, but does so by requiring the aperture be fixed near its open position. The Sweep Panorama mode can function in either 2D or 3D variants, and allows capture and in-camera stitching of multi-shot panoramic images by simply pressing the shutter button and sweeping the camera across the subject. A selection of user-friendly scene modes accessed through the Scene position include Portrait, Sports Action, Macro, Landscape, Sunset, Night view, Hand-held Twilight, and Night Portrait, and let beginners get the look they're aiming for, without needing to understand the subtleties of shutter speeds, apertures, and the like.
The Sony A33 uses the image sensor itself when metering, and considers the overall image as 1,200 separate zones in performing metering calculations. Metering modes include Multi-segment, Center-weighted, and Spot, and the metering system can function from -2 EV to +17 EV (at ISO 100 equivalent with an F1.4 lens). An autoexposure lock button is provided, allowing metering to be locked from a specific portion of the subject, then the overall image reframed as desired. +/-2.0 EV of exposure compensation is available, in 1/3 EV steps. The A33 also offers a three-frame exposure bracketing function, which allows a step size of either 1/3 or 2/3 EV between subsequent frames. Shutter speeds from 1/4,000 to 30 seconds are available, as well as a bulb position that holds the shutter open for as long as the shutter release is pressed. Flash X-sync is at 1/160 second. White balance options include auto, six presets (Daylight, Shade, Cloudy, Incandescent, Fluorescent, and Flash), plus both custom and direct color temperature (2,500 to 9,900K) options. The six presets allow +/- 3 step adjustment, and there's also a color filter setting that provides +/-9 steps of magenta / green compensation.
Flash. The Sony A33 includes an auto-popup flash strobe with a guide number of 10 meters at ISO 100, as well as a proprietary flash hot shoe. The built-in flash has 18mm coverage, and a recycle time of four seconds. Flash modes include Auto, Auto w/ Red-eye reduction, Fill, Fill w/ Red-eye Reduction, Slow-sync, and Rear-sync. Flash metering modes include ADI and pre-flash TTL. +/-2 EV of flash exposure compensation is available, in 1/3 EV steps, and flash exposures can also be bracketed, with three frames varying by 1/3 or 2/3 EV. External strobes including the HVL-F36AM, HVL-F42AM, HVL-F56AM, and HVL-F58AM support high-speed sync and wireless shooting.
Movie mode. The Sony A33 offers high definition interlaced video capture at up to 1,920 x 1,080 pixel resolution, commonly known as "Full HD" or "1080i." While Full HD videos are recorded using 59.94i or 50i interlaced field rates, the actual sensor data is clocked off at a frame rate of 29.97 or 25 frames per second. Using the non-standard 1,440 x 1,080 and standard definition VGA 640 x 480 pixel modes, progressive scan videos are created, matching the same actual sensor frame rates. One quirk of the A33's design is that when shooting VGA videos, the focal length crop is increased just slightly, yielding a video feed that appears to have been shot with a more powerful telephoto lens (and in the process, making wide-angle video harder to achieve). The closely related A55 model doesn't share this feature, which we'd speculate is likely due to some limitation as to how data can be most efficiently clocked off the CMOS image sensor in video mode.
Maximum video length is 29 minutes or two gigabytes per clip, whichever limit is reached first -- although if SteadyShot is enabled, this limit is slashed to just nine minutes per clip, likely due to sensor heating issues when using the sensor-shift stabilization mechanism. Full HD videos are recorded using 17Mbps AVCHD compression, while the lower resolutions are saved with MP4 compression, at a bitrate of 12Mbps for 1,440 x 1,080 pixel video, or 3Mbps for VGA video. Movie capture is started and stopped with a dedicated Movie button located just to the right of the electronic viewfinder, within easy reach of a thumb press.
The most unusual capability of the Sony Alpha A33's video mode is enabled by its translucent mirror. The Sony A33 can continue to use phase detection autofocusing during movie recording, allowing swift adjustments to focus as your subject moves. Since standard Alpha-mount lenses are used, this focusing action is accompanied by significant levels of AF drive noise, which is clearly picked up by the camera in recorded videos. For consumers, this is likely a relatively small price to pay for sharply focused video, however, given that manually pulling focus during video capture is a difficult art to learn. If focus point selection is set to local, the Sony A33 even allows the active focus point to be changed during video capture, and it's also possible to adjust exposure compensation during recording. Also available in Movie mode are the autoexposure lock function to prevent variations in scene brightness, and white balance, creative style, AF area and metering mode functions. However, if autofocus is used, lens aperture must be controlled automatically by the camera, regardless of AF servo mode. When using manual focus, the A33 allows manual control of aperture before video capture commences. In all cases, shutter speed and ISO sensitivity of videos is controlled automatically.
The Sony A33 includes an internal stereo microphone, actually comprising two separate monaural microphones located on either side of the electronic viewfinder / flash housing. It can also accept external stereo microphones, courtesy of a 3.5mm jack on the left side of the camera body. Alternatively, sound recording in videos can be disabled, if preferred. The built-in speaker in the Sony A33 is monaural, and there's no manual control over audio recording levels.
Dust reduction. The Sony A33 has a dust abatement and removal system. A charge-protection coating on the low-pass filter aims to prevent dust adhering in the first place. The sensor shift mechanism used to provide SteadyShot image stabilization also doubles as a shake mechanism to try and free stubborn dust particles that settle on the low-pass filter, although at much lower frequencies than the vibration induced by cameras using a piezoelectric element. From what we can tell, there is no strategy for keeping dust off the translucent mirror, except to blow the surface gently with air; it cannot be cleaned, and should never be touched. A fingerprint would require replacement at a service center.
Tilt level. The Sony A33 includes a dual-axis level gauge, which helps ensure level horizons and prevent converging verticals in photos. The level gauge can be shown on either the electronic viewfinder or the rear-panel LCD, but only alongside the most basic information overlay -- you can't combine the detailed display overlays with the level gauge. A clever way around it, though, is to set one viewer to the level gauge, and the other to a more informative display, since by default you can set the display modes independently. There's no way for the user to recalibrate the gauge, if they find the factory default to be inaccurate. The gauge is displayed in a style reminiscent of an aircraft attitude indicator, but with a separation of the roll and pitch indicators. When the camera is perfectly level, the pitch indicators and markings at the end of the roll indicator are illuminated in green.
User interface. Sony has retained a similar menu system in the Sony A33 to that previously featured in the Alpha series DSLRs, but incorporating the new database-driven Playback mode from the NEX-series SLD models. The user interface of the Sony A33 is generally clean and easy to understand, with the one major exception being the rather arbitrary segregation of still images and videos in playback mode. Switching between viewing stills and videos requires the user to either enter the menu system, or zoom out to the thumbnail view and select the appropriate tab. Neither option is immediately obvious without reading the manual, and photographers unfamiliar with the interface might believe they'd accidentally deleted the unavailable media, not realizing they were simply in the wrong viewing mode.
Special features. The Sony Alpha A33 incorporates a variety of unusual features that have appeared previously in the company's NEX and Cyber-shot series digital cameras, including Sweep Panorama, 3D Sweep Panorama, Auto High Dynamic Range, and Handheld Twilight modes. Each of these modes automatically captures several images, microaligns them, and then combines them into one image with attributes that couldn't have been achieved in a single still.
The Sweep Panorama modes create lengthy panoramic images with a single sweep over the scene, and do a good job of automatically correcting for uneven panning, although they do sometimes show stairstepping in nearby subjects. The 3D variant is particularly unusual, in that it calculates separate left and right-eye views by comparing the positions of subjects as seen by the left and right sides of the lens. The result is saved as a multi-picture object file containing separate left- and right-eye JPEG views of the scene, for viewing on 3D displays.
Auto High Dynamic Range mode captures numerous images with varied exposure, then creates a single image with much greater dynamic range than would otherwise be possible.
Handheld Twilight mode captures a batch of high-ISO images, reducing blur from camera shake, and then averages the aligned exposures so as to reduce image noise. A new Multi-Frame NR mode acts similarly, but allows the ISO sensitivity to be selected manually, allowing use even at lower sensitivities. Of course, these effects could all be achieved in a PC with some work and know-how, but what's impressive is that they're now available with a minimum of fuss, in-camera. To ensure that even inexperienced photographers can derive benefit from these features, Sony has also created a new Auto+ exposure mode that can identify when these functions might be of use, and then enable them automatically.
Storage and battery. The Sony Alpha A33 offers a single flash memory card slot, but it's compatible with two memory card standards, each with various permutations. The first is Memory Stick PRO Duo / PRO-HG Duo, Sony's own proprietary media format. As an alternative for those who prefer more standardized media, Sony also supports three flavors of Secure Digital cards -- standard SD, SDHC, and SDXC.
The Sony Alpha A33 uses a 7.2V, 1020mAh InfoLITHIUM battery pack, with part number NP-FW50. Tested to the CIPA standard, the Sony Alpha A33 is rated at the lowest battery life among its SLT-series siblings, with 340 LCD shots, or 270 shots with the EVF. That's perhaps a little surprising, given that it lacks the built-in GPS receiver of the A55V, has a lower-resolution image sensor yielding less data to process, a reduced shooting speed, and less buffer memory. By way of comparison, the A55V captures 380 shots with the LCD, or 330 shots with the EVF, while the A55 can manage 390 shots on the LCD, or 350 with the EVF.
Sony Alpha A55/33 Field Test
by Dave Etchells
Combining breakthrough translucent-mirror technology with Sony's high-speed CMOS sensor prowess, the new Sony Alpha A33 and A55 break important new ground for consumer SLRs. Both deliver higher capture speeds than other consumer-class digital SLR, at 7 and 10 frames per second respectively, as well as true phase-detect live autofocus during video recording. Thrown in multi-shot technology (Handheld Twilight, Sweep Panorama, and Auto HDR modes) brought over from Sony's digicam line, and the new cameras offer features not found in any other SLR, regardless of price point.
I had a chance to spend a few days with a late prototype of the Sony A55 (equipped with production firmware version 1.0) prior to its release. (Note that the Sony A33 is so similar to the A55, that we've only made a few edits to this Field Test to make it work for the A33 review.) After running a couple thousand shots through it (it does have a very fast continuous mode) I found it to be a pretty compelling camera, combining remarkable shooting speed with a host of other capabilities that really set it apart from most of the market. It's by no means perfect, but unquestionably expands the range of shooting capabilities open to consumers with average pocketbooks. Looking at just how much I found to comment on below underscores for me just how much Sony has done in the last few months. Read on for some of my thoughts on this new class of consumer SLR:
In the Hand
Leaving their advanced capabilities aside, the Sony A33 and A55 are also remarkably compact cameras. As we've noted elsewhere, because the mirror in the camera isn't used to form a viewfinder image, it can be mounted at a steeper angle than normal, removing some thickness from the camera body as a whole (the flange-sensor distance must obviously remain the same, but there's more room in the body for the shake-reduction system and other electronics), and the space normally required for the mirror drive system could be trimmed from the sides. As a result, the body is noticeably compact.
I'm always a little torn over really small camera bodies, as it can be uncomfortable to twist my longer-than-average fingers around a small handgrip. That said, I really didn't find the smallish grip on the Sony A55 too objectionable. The design of the front grip naturally encourages my middle and third fingers to curve downward, my pinkie to fold underneath the body, and to carry the weight of the camera on my middle finger, between the second and third knuckle. My customary two-handed SLR grip, with one hand on the lens' zoom ring made for a comfortable and secure hold.
Grip comfort/security is greatly aided by the deeply sculpted thumbrest on the camera's back. Combined with the textured rubber used over the whole right half of the body, it provides a very secure gripping point for my thumb, and does a lot to make up for the small size of the front grip. The rubber coating also contributes to a feel of solid build quality, by damping the body vibrations that often make small and light cameras feel tinny or cheap.
I did find the small body and grip a little problematic when shooting with a long or heavy lens, though: I spent quite a bit of time with the excellent Sony 70-200mm f/2.8 mounted on the camera, and did experience some wrist fatigue by the end of the day. Since the camera is capable of very fast live autofocus during video recording, I often found myself wanting to zoom during the recording, something that would be anathema on a conventional video-capable SLR. Doing so required that I carry more of the weight of the lens/camera assembly on my right hand, so my left could operate the zoom ring more smoothly. The result was a lot of weight for my right wrist to carry, and the small grip made it more difficult than otherwise. When shooting normally with smaller lenses, though, I never found the grip uncomfortable.
The control buttons are for the most part intelligently arranged and readily accessible, but the small space available for them on the right side of the body does mean that you need to hold the camera in your left hand to be able to access them properly: They're really too close to the right side of the camera to keep your fingers wrapped around the grip and operate the buttons with any degree of comfort. On the angled top/back panel, the EV adjust button is perfectly located, right under your thumb, with the AE lock and movie recording buttons on either side of it. The movie button does require a deliberate reach to get to, but is nonetheless easy to identify by feel when you're looking through the viewfinder; just slide your thumb over until it hits the viewfinder housing, and you'll be right on top of the movie button.
Many of the Sony A55 and A33's settings are accessed via the Fn button, just below and the to the left of the thumb grip recess on the back of the camera. I can't think of any better place to put it, but accessing it does require loosening your grip, and therefore shifting support from your right hand to your left. Apart from that, the Fn button is in a good location, easy to find by feel: Just slide your thumb down out of its recess, and the Fn button is the first control you'll touch.
Adjusting settings via the Fn menu is generally a good experience. A very nice touch is that you can use the up/down/left/right directions of the 4-way controller to move the cursor between Fn menu items, and then use the front control dial to adjust the settings. This is nice because it lets you quickly make a number of Fn settings changes in succession, without having to drop down a menu level for each, or being forced out of the Fn menu between choices. The few exceptions to this are those items with a second level of control, such as multi-shot ISO or the tweak adjustments for white balance settings. In those cases, you need to explicitly select the menu item via the OK button, and then use the left/right keys to make the needed adjustment. The only exit at that point is to hit the OK button again, which unfortunately drops you out of the Fn menu entirely.
One nice thing about the Sony A55 and A33's electronic viewfinder is that the Fn menu is also available in the viewfinder display; you can make many camera settings without taking your eye from the viewfinder eyepiece. As I became more familiar with the camera's controls, this led to a very efficient shooting style, although it would take more than the few days I've had with the camera thus far for this to become second nature.
Electronic Viewfinder Display
In reviewing my experience with the Sony A55 and A33, it's interesting to find so many of my notes and so much of my attention directed to the viewfinder display. Were I not already so familiar with Sony's multi-shot exposure technology, the camera's multi-shot features would doubtless have commanded more of my attention, as they're worthy features indeed. That said, though, the viewfinder turned out to be absolutely integral to my experience with the camera.
Where a conventional SLR has an optical viewfinder, the Sony A33/55 substitutes an electronic display with an eyepiece attached. (An electronic viewfinder, or EVF for short.) The image for the EVF is taken from the main image sensor, so the camera is essentially always in "Live View" mode. Mechanically, the eyepiece projects out from the back of the camera a fair bit, to leave room for the camera's autofocus system in front of the EVFs micro display and viewfinder optics. I found I actually liked this rear projection, as it left a bit more room for my nose when I held the camera to my eye. Happily, the neckstrap eyelets are arranged such that the camera hangs lens-down when on a neck strap, so I had no trouble with the projecting eyepiece poking me in the chest.
I have to say up front that I've never been a fan of EVFs. While they do permit much more information overlay than conventional optical viewfinders, I've always felt that EVFs' limitations have outweighed their advantages. In particular, EVFs usually have limited sensitivity and dynamic range, not to mention low refresh rates and poor resolution when compared with the view through a conventional optical viewfinder.
Given my long-term dislike of EVFs, I was surprised to find myself as comfortable as I was with the one on the Sony A55 and A33. It by no means corrects all the ills of the genre, but does go a long way in the right direction. It still loses highlight detail in scenes with both deep shadows and strong highlights, but I found it workable most of the time. I could generally make out clouds against the sky, important for framing landscape shots. It also seemed to do pretty well under low light conditions, although as of this writing, I haven't done a lot of night photography with the camera. Still, the large pixels of the Sony A33's APS-C size sensor mean that its EVF is much more able to form a usable viewfinder image under dim lighting than is that of a typical digicam. Under really dark conditions, I'd still like to see it gain-up a bit more, though, even at the cost of slower refresh rates.
The time-multiplexed full-color RGB pixel technology generally worked well to deliver very high resolution with no gaps at all between the pixels. The only place I was aware of the EVF pixels were in diagonal strokes of letters on the various VF info readouts, or on the electronic level display, when the indicator lines were tilted. I never saw pixel jaggies when looking at the subjects I was shooting, even in the case of sharp high-contrast edges.
The one thing some users might find distracting about the Sony A33's EVF is the RGB "rainbows" you can see when either your eye, the subject, or the camera is moving rapidly. Each pixel of the display shows its red, green, and blue information sequentially, so if the viewfinder image is moving rapidly relative to your eye, you'll see red, green, and blue ghosts or trails around bright objects. I didn't notice this at all until someone pointed it out to me, but after they did, it became unreasonably annoying for a while. After a couple of days of shooting with the camera, though, I again became largely unaware of it and now have to deliberately look for it to be aware of the effect.
On the Sony A33 and A55, the EVF can serve as both shooting and playback display. As mentioned earlier, the ability to check your shots and make camera settings without taking your eye from the eyepiece leads to a slightly different and more efficient shooting style; one that encourages you to learn the camera by feel and memory, rather than looking at the controls as you press them. I've only had a few days with the camera as of this writing, but can see that greater familiarity will produce a very efficient shooting style.
A final benefit of the EVF is that it lets you keep the camera to your eye during video recording, something no other SLR currently offers, although some SLDs do.
I've left perhaps the most salient characteristic of the Sony AF55 and A33's EVF till last: It's huge. The view through the Sony A33's eyepiece is much more akin to that of a full-frame DSLR than that of any competing sub-frame model currently on the market. It manages this with a comfortably high eye point (and plenty of dioptric adjustment) for eyeglass wearers, at least when simply viewing the live viewfinder image itself.
It turns out that the live viewfinder image doesn't cover the full screen in 3:2 aspect mode, but is normally confined to roughly the central 80% of the available display area. When you switch to the Fn menu display, though, you need to press your eye pretty close to the viewfinder eyepiece to be able to see the menu items on the left and right sides of the screen. I found that with my eyeglasses on, I had to shift my eye to the left or the right to see the menu entries on the sides, or else really mash my eyeglasses against the eyecup. Switching to 16:9 aspect ratio expands the image to fill the left and right of the EVF's LCD as well, which is also problematic for eyeglass wearers.
Interestingly, I didn't notice the unusual size of Sony A33's viewfinder display when I first picked up the camera, but I became acutely aware of its loss when I switched back to a conventional sub-frame DSLR after having shot with the Sony A55 and A33 for a day or so. The conventional DSLR suddenly felt I was looking down a tunnel, and I also found myself greatly missing the richness of the A33's viewfinder information overlays. The excellent image quality of the Sony A33's EVF did a lot to win me over to the idea of EVFs on interchangeable-lens cameras, but it was the combination of image size and informational richness that really put me over the top. Because it could appear right there in the viewfinder, rather than on the rear-panel LCD, I was surprised to see how much I came to rely on the electronic level display for keeping my landscape shots straight when there was no obvious horizon line.
Bottom line, while the Sony A33's EVF doesn't entirely conquer the challenges of its genre, it goes further in the right direction than any other I've experienced to date. Most telling is that I now find myself reluctant to give up its benefits and return to world of purely optical viewfinders once again.
Sony A33 Rear-Panel LCD
The potentially game-changing performance of the Sony A33's EVF overshadows its excellent rear-panel LCD, which is a little unfair: It's as good an LCD as is found on any other camera, and in at least one sense literally outshines them all. It's the same widescreen ~920K-dot high-resolution LCD we've seen now on a wide range of cameras from a variety of makers, but its implementation on the Sony A33 adds a couple of useful twists. First, of course, it literally twists and rotates, albeit from the bottom of the body, rather than the side. This unfortunately makes it useless for composing self-portraits with the camera mounted on a tripod, but otherwise is quite helpful for getting over-the-head and ground-level shots with ease.
The second upgrade to the Sony A33's LCD is the TruBlack technology we first saw on other recent Sony cameras. This is a combination of anti-reflective coatings and a darker mask around the LCD pixels, to keep shadow areas darker. It does seem to be an improvement over LCDs lacking it, but to my eyes, the difference isn't dramatic.
The LCD improvement I found most the most dramatically useful was the brightness settings. Set to Auto brightness, the camera will brighten or dim the LCD display in response to ambient light. This helps a good bit in bright daylight, but the display still washes out in direct sunlight. If you're shooting in bright sun, though, check out the Sony A33's "Sunny Weather" LCD brightness setting. Wow - That's a really bright display! It does blow out the top end of the display's tone curve (that is, you won't see any detail in the highlights in your images in this mode), but this is the first time I can honestly say that I had no trouble viewing a camera's LCD screen in direct sunlight. It's a really great feature, although I'm sure it further reduces the Sony A33's already-short battery life.
Sony A33 High Speed Shooting
As explained elsewhere here, a major point of the Sony A33/55's translucent mirror technology is to permit autofocus operation and image exposure to overlap each other, enabling very fast continuous burst shooting with accurate autofocus tracking. They in fact do a remarkable job of delivering 7fps or 10fps full-resolution shooting speeds, although in some respects, the experience is still rather different than shooting with high-end pro SLRs with that sort of burst capability. The heart of the difference has to do with what image the Sony A33 is showing you through the viewfinder at any given moment.
High-end professional SLRs drop the mirror between exposures, providing a direct (however brief) view of the subject between shots. In contrast, in their highest-speed capture modes, the Sony A33 and A55 display a static image of the shot they've just captured. Rather than seeing interrupted glimpses of your subject in motion, the A55 displays a procession of still images, each lagging the subject motion.
I'm not remotely an experienced sports shooter, so I can have trouble tracking fast-moving subjects under the best of circumstances. Already finding tracking fast action closely challenging, I found tracking fast action closely based on a series of static images delayed by 1/10 second or more was quite a bit harder still. After a little practice, I got better at doing so, but I sometimes found myself resorting to tricks like keeping both eyes open while shooting, or shooting in short bursts and using the time between bursts to get the subject properly framed with full-time live view again.
I found the Sony A33 and A55's AF tracking to be very fast and pretty accurate; almost too fast in some cases: If I let the central AF point wander off the subject for a fraction of a second, focus would quickly shift to the background. Many of the missed-focus shots I took were the result of this problem, versus the camera not being able to track focus quickly enough. Some high-end DSLRs have settings in their autofocus systems to adjust how quickly they respond to momentary loss of the subject. (Either from the AF point drifting off the subject, or for some interfering object passing between the subject and camera.) If Sony were able to add this capability to the A33/55, it could go a long way to reducing the number of missed shots, at least based on my experience.
Fast AF tracking
|This sequence gives some idea of the Sony A33 and A55's autofocus tracking ability (these shots were taken with the A55). The subject was a car, approaching the camera at constant rate of 30 miles/hour. In the first shot of the series, the car was perhaps 70 feet from the camera, in the last shot, it's perhaps 15 feet away. Images were shot at a focal length of 150mm, with a Sony 70-200mm f/2.8 G lens. There are a few minor bobbles, but the fourth image of the series was actually blurred by camera motion, not AF error. We shot side by side with the Sony A55 and a Canon 7D, and thought that the A55's AF performance here was pretty similar to that of the much more expensive Canon.|
While the Sony A33 and A55's viewfinder display led to a bit of a learning curve for tracking fast action, its buffer-clearing speed is an ongoing issue. The A55 can capture shots with amazing speed, but once its buffer is filled, things slow down dramatically. The A33, for its part, has a smaller buffer, but it takes less time to clear. The most irritating point with the A55 was that it seemed to take forever before it would let me look at what I'd just shot. This is certainly more of an issue for a relatively inexperienced user than a pro sports photographer, but I often found myself wanting to check out what I'd just shot before the next action sequence started so I could note and correct for any problems in my shooting style. If I'd filled the buffer, though, it took upwards of 15-18 seconds before I could even view the first image on the LCD -- and a good while longer before the buffer was completely empty and the camera was back to its maximum burst-length capacity. Shoot RAW+JPEG and it takes 32 seconds to clear a maximum of 18 images, while the A33 only captures 7 images and takes 12 seconds to clear. Advantage A33.
This dead-screen issue was so pronounced that I found myself dropping back to 6 fps rather than 10 on the A55, and shooting in short bursts at what I thought (hoped?) were the decisive moments. More than with many cameras with lesser speed or buffer capacity, I found myself shooting to manage the camera's buffer, more than simply focusing on the subject and the action taking place. It would have been a lot less aggravating if I could have at least seen thumbnails of just-captured shots immediately after taking them.
For all my complaining about the difficulty of tracking sports subjects and the dead-screen issue, though, the difference between these SLTs and other consumer-level DSLRs is little short of astonishing. It may not be a direct substitute for a Canon 1D Mark IV or Nikon D3s, but if you have a budget of under $1,000 and shoot any fast action at all, the Sony A55 and A33 are hands-down slam-dunk purchase decisions. At this point, there's nothing else in the large-sensor segment of the digital camera market that remotely approaches their high-speed capture capabilities.
Sony A33: Speed isn't just for sports
This is an important enough point that I felt it deserved its own heading: High speed shooting isn't just about sports photography; it's about capturing the perfect moment, regardless of how fast the subject is moving. This is a point I've been making since I first tested a prototype of the Casio FH20 a couple of years ago: The difference between the perfect moment of blowing out the birthday candles and one that's a near miss can be a small fraction of a second. When shooting candids of people chatting and interacting, facial expressions and mouth positions change in literally the blink of an eye. A camera that shoots at 7 frames per second vs. one that only manages 3 frames per second can mean the difference between dozens of "keepers" and just a few.
If you enjoy people photography and delight in taking photos revealing real character and emotion, get yourself a Sony A33 and a large memory card, set the camera to high-speed continuous mode, and let fly. You'll be amazed at how much more intimate and impactful your photos become.
Special "Sony" modes
While the Sony A55 and A33's singular claim to fame is its exceptional shooting speed, that's only part of what it has to offer. Just in the last year, Sony has used its high-speed sensor technology to create a number of innovative new camera features that, on their face, have nothing to do with high-speed shooting. This hands-on report is already running far too long, so I'll just make brief mention of some of these special Sony modes here. Even if you feel no need for 7 to 10 fps capture in your personal shooting, these special exposure modes alone would be reason enough to buy one of these cameras.
Handheld Twilight mode
We first saw this feature in Sony's DSC-TX1 and DSC-WX1 in mid-2009. Since then, it's been mimicked by other manufacturers, but none seem to do it as well as Sony. In Handheld Twilight mode, the camera captures up to 6 shots in rapid succession, micro-aligns them with each other, and then adds them all together. The net result is that you can hand-hold ridiculously long exposures and still get sharp results, with very low image noise to boot. Combine this with Sony's SteadyShot image stabilization and sharp handheld photos at half-second exposure times are feasible.
Personally, I find Handheld Twilight mode to be one of the most useful camera features I've seen in recent memory. The freedom to shoot handheld under dim lighting is enormously liberating, opening up lots of photo opportunities that I'd have had to pass on previously. It's the reason I frequently grab a Sony camera for snapshots when I'm going on a personal outing.
Multi-Frame Noise Reduction mode
Handheld Twilight is a scene mode on the Sony A33 and A55, so it doesn't offer you much control: The camera picks the ISO setting, shutter speed, etc, that it thinks is best, and takes the picture. About all you can control is whether to enable face detection AF or not. For those wanting the multi-shot advantages but with more creative control, Sony offers Multi-Frame Noise Reduction mode. This mode lets you select the ISO you want to use, but the camera micro-aligns and averages together six shots, significantly reducing ISO noise. You get the same basic capability as in Handheld Twilight mode, but retain full control over other exposure parameters.
If Handheld Twilight and Multi-Frame NR modes are practical, Sweep Panorama is just plain fun. I've always been a fan of panoramic images, and spent more time than I care to remember back in the film days slicing and splicing together 4x6-inch prints with a razor blade and rubber cement, to make panoramas from sequences of individual shots. The Sony A33 and A55's Sweep Panorama mode does all this for you inside the camera. Again taking advantage of Sony's high-speed capture technology, Sweep Panorama collects dozens of individual images while you hold down the shutter button and "sweep" the camera from side to side or up and down. The powerful Bionz image-processing engine examines all these images, takes slices from each, applies geometric and tonal corrections to each slice, and then stitches them together into a single panoramic image. The results are stunning, and experimenting is loads of fun.
Pretty slick, but not infallible
The camera can't always perfectly compensate for how you move the camera during the panorama, nor for extreme perspective shifts, so you'll sometimes see "stitch errors" in the assembled shots. The slight "stuttering" above left in a shot from the Sony A55 is typical of the mild errors that sometimes occur: Pretty unobtrusive, unless you really zoom in to pixel-peep. More dramatic errors like the crop from an A560 panorama seen above right were fairly rare in my experience. This is a great feature for dramatic vacation snapshots, but if you're making panoramas professionally, you'll still want to build them manually from separate shots.
Sweep Panorama mode makes shooting panoramas easy, but not entirely brainless: It often takes me a few tries to get just the shot I want. The camera throws away a fair bit of the image area top/bottom and left/right, to insure that it has enough room to get everything aligned properly, despite your having angled the camera or not having swept perfectly horizontally or vertically. Sometimes, you can end up with your main subject higher or lower in the frame than you'd anticipated. It's also easy to get a tilted horizon, if the camera orientation or your sweep direction is a little off. I found the A33 and A55's level indicator and viewfinder gridline displays very helpful for avoiding these problems, although there was a little learning curve for me to make effective use of them.
3D Sweep Panorama
In case you hadn't noticed, 2010 is the Year of 3D in the HDTV space, and all the television makers are rushing to add 3D capability across their product lines. Sony has come up with a clever way of capturing 3D images using the same "sweep" technology as in their normal 2D panoramas. As the camera is swept across a scene, it will naturally see various parts of the subject from slightly different angles at different points along its sweep. Sony's engineers have taken advantage of this to add a 3D Sweep Panorama mode to a number of their cameras, the A33 and A55 included. While the 3D data is apparently stored in a fairly standard file format, viewing the 3D images currently requires connecting the camera's HDMI output to a Sony 3D-capable television set. Sony's promised 3D Sweep Panorama playback support for their PS3 game consoles, supposedly coming as early as this September. That's still a bit limiting, but hopefully as 3D technology matures, various manufacturers will be able to read each others' 3D formats.
If you have a 3D-capable Sony television to view them on, capturing 3D images can definitely be entertaining. That's about where I'd leave it, though: "Entertaining" vs "compelling." While you do get a reasonable 3D effect in shots captured this way, I found the quality of the 3D experience a little disappointing. Don't expect Avatar-level 3D, this strikes me as more of a gee-whiz sort of feature: In my experience, the 3D effect is a bit limited, and foreground objects tend to break up visually. I suspect this has to do with the fact that the perspective is changing throughout the sweep, so things like effective intraocular distance and viewing angle aren't perfectly consistent throughout the image. Whatever the cause, it's a fun effect, but not something that would be a decisive factor for me in choosing a camera, whereas ordinary 2D sweep panorama is something that I've used often. (Personally, I suspect this feature has a lot less to do with selling cameras than it does with selling TVs: I wouldn't buy a camera for the feature, but all else being equal, if I owned a Sony camera that had the feature, I'd be more inclined to purchase a Sony television that supported it.)
There's one more multi-shot feature on the Sony A33 that's worth mentioning; namely Auto HDR (High Dynamic Range). HDR photography increases the range of brightness values represented in a scene by combining two or more shots taken at different exposures, combining highlight detail from some and shadow detail from others. In the past, this has involved locking the camera down on a tripod, shooting several images at different exposures, and then working on a computer to combine them. Lately, though, the capability to do this directly in-camera has been appearing from a number of manufacturers, with varying levels of success. The auto HDR feature on the Sony A33 works pretty well, since the camera does the same micro-alignment trick it uses for its other multi-shot features. Options for HDR include an Auto setting, where the camera determines how much of the effect to apply, and manual settings ranging from 1 to 6(!) EV of exposure range.
HDR is a feature that's easy to over-use, as it can quickly over-flatten the contrast of an image, resulting in a dull, lifeless photo. On the other hand, there are times when nothing else will do. I've shot a lot of landscape images over the years where I've really wished I had it; situations where there was bright sky and deep shadows, or a bright rockface but also interesting detail I wanted to capture that was in the shade. With an auto-HDR option, I often find myself trying it, but also shooting a normally exposed shot as well. I more often like the normal shot, but sometimes the HDR one is the keeper. (I really wish there were an option to have the camera capture three shots; a normally-exposed one and the the high/low exposure pair it uses to build the HDR image from. It'd be handy to be able to shoot a normal image, with the HDR shot as backup.)
Sony DRO (Dynamic Range Optimization)
Actually, while HDR is the more glamorous feature, Sony's Dynamic Range Optimizer (DRO for short) deserves some attention, as I found myself relying more on it than HDR to manage tonal extremes. Most every camera company has some sort of an exposure mode that adjusts exposure and/or contrast to help avoid blowing highlights or plugging shadows. After several years of tweaking, I think that images shot with Sony's DRO now look better than most. DRO defaults to the Auto setting on the Sony A33 and A55, and most times I checked, I liked the tonal balance of photos shot that way over that those with DRO turned off.
Sony A33 Video Shooting
Video capture is an area where the Sony A33's translucent mirror technology makes a huge difference relative to pretty any other SLR currently on the market, and relative to even fast-focusing SLDs. Every other interchangeable-lens camera currently on the market either doesn't autofocus at all when recording videos, or has to resort to slower and/or more obtrusive contrast-detect focusing. Because the Sony A33's phase-detect AF system is always looking at the subject, fast autofocus during video recording is no problem.
Phase-detect AF isn't just faster, though, it's much less noticeable in your videos. Because phase-detect AF actually measures the amount of mis-focus, it can command the lens to go directly to the correct focus setting, without "hunting" back and forth. By comparison, contrast-detect AF has to try different focus settings one after another, checking to see whether each amounted to better or worse focus than the one that preceded it. This can be quite distracting in the recorded video, as you can visibly see the focus shifting back and forth, even when the subject isn't moving. Have a look at the video above left which shows pretty fast, sure-footed focus when the subject is changed. (See our Sony A33 Video page for more details and sample videos.)
It's not all a bed of roses with video and live AF on the Sony A33, though. While it tracks action very well, focus actuation with the kit lens is far from silent: In anything but a very loud environment, the "chock... chock" of the lens' focus operation is painfully apparent in the audio track. Even with the ultrasonic motor-equipped Sony 70-200mm f/2.8G lens attached, focus noise was quite audible in quiet environments. Another really annoying (and entirely avoidable) audio artifact is the loud click that's recorded at the very end of each video clip; the sound of your pressing the video on/off button to stop the recording. I experienced this with the NEX-5 as well, and it honestly seems like a bug to me.
Overall, there's little question that the Sony A33 has the best video AF of any interchangeable-lens camera currently on the market, but if you plan on doing much video recording, I'd suggest you also plan on buying an accessory external microphone to record the audio.
Sony A33 Exposure Accuracy
While we didn't encounter any exposure accuracy issues in our lab tests, I had a little trouble with the Sony A33 and A55's exposure system in the field. Under bright sunlight, I was generally shooting with -0.3 EV of exposure compensation dialed in. Looking at my photos on the computer later, it seemed that many of them really could have used -0.7 EV. The overexposure bias seemed fairly universal under bright lighting, regardless of whether the subject itself was low- or high-key. Shots under lower lighting didn't seem to have the same issue, though.
Besides the overexposure bias, I also found the A33's metering system was prone to more variation than I'm accustomed to seeing in an SLR. The few times I had it locked down on a tripod, shot to shot exposure seemed pretty consistent, but on several occasions shooting handheld, I found significant variation between successive shots, apparently resulting from fairly minor changes in framing. I'd of course expect exposure to vary to follow changes in the scene, but the amount of variation I saw between very similar shots taken with the A33 was unusual.
Sony A33 Battery Life (or not)
The one negative that most stands out in my mind for the Sony A33 actually has the least to do with its abilities as a camera. The first thing that comes to mind when thinking about shooting with it isn't whether I'll be able to bring back the shots I want with it, but rather whether the battery will last long enough to do so. We have no doubt that the Sony A33 will meet the fairly generous shot-life numbers quoted under the CIPA specs (340 shots with the LCD, 270 with the EVF), but in actual practice, with the camera rattling off hundreds of shots in amazingly short order, what most struck me was just how fast I seemed to run out of battery life. It's quite easy to run through a full battery in just a couple of hours of active shooting, and two batteries should be considered a minimum for a day of serious shooting.
In the old days, we were always careful to remind readers to purchase a second battery along with their camera, but in recent years, battery life has become much less of a concern than it once was. Not so with the Sony A33, though: Unless you intend it only for light snap-shooting, consider the purchase of a second battery mandatory.
In the Box
The retail kit contains the following items:
- Sony Alpha SLT-A33 body
- SAL-1855 SAM lens
- Lithium-ion battery pack NP-FW50
- Battery charger BC-VW1
- USB cable
- Body cap
- Lens cap
- Shoulder strap
- Software CD-ROM
- Extra battery pack for extended outings
- Fast, large capacity SDHC memory card. These days, 4GB is a good tradeoff between cost and capacity, but if you plan to capture many movie clips, 8GB should be a minimum.
Sony A33 Conclusion
While I found enough to quibble about to justify my role as a reviewer, I also found the Sony A55 and A33 to be uniquely compelling cameras. The most telling point was how hard I found it going back to an "ordinary" SLR after just a day of shooting with the A55. I've long been an avowed EVF-hater, but the viewfinder display on the Sony A55 is good enough that I found myself sorely missing it when I returned to shooting with a conventional sub-frame SLR with a typically small optical viewfinder. The Sony A55's shooting speed matches that of professional models costing literally thousands of dollars more thanks to the unique pellicle mirror design, and its uniquely Sony features (Handheld Twilight/Multi-Frame NR and Sweep Panorama modes in particular) take the A55 places no other SLR has gone before. I was also pleasantly surprised by how comfortable the Sony A55's grip was, given the tiny body size. I still prefer having more to wrap my fingers around, but this is as good a grip as I've seen on an SLR body this compact to date. While its primary target clearly is not the entry-level shooter, the Sony A55's Auto+ mode takes it closer to true "just push the button" simplicity in auto mode than any other camera we're aware of, enabling novice-level users to enjoy the multi-shot and other Scene modes without having to worry about which to use when. At the other end of the spectrum, for the enthusiast with time to become acquainted its capabilities and familiar with its quirks, the Sony A55 expands the realm of amateur photography further than any SLR to date. In the A55 and A33, Sony has used outside-the-box thinking to deliver a uniquely capable, functional, and well-designed SLR. Hot on the heels of their category-redefining NEX-3 and NEX-5, Sony's engineers have now likewise redefined what consumers can expect from an SLR.
For maximum resolution and shooting speed, plus built-in GPS, choose the Sony A55. Give up a little speed and resolution and drop the GPS, though, and you can save upwards of $200 with the Sony A33.
Buy the Sony A33
$1215.50 (56% more)
20.2 MP (30% more)
Also has viewfinder
1 $300 Adorama Gift Certificate
2 $200 Adorama Gift Certificate
3 $100 Adorama Gift Certificate